Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along?

Hacker News by 3 min read 34x views
Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along?

Share Post

There’s a average idea among economists that you can broadly divided workforce into two categories. “White-collar” workers are typically group who activity in offices doing service-based, knowledge-based, managerial, or administrative work; “blue-collar” workers mostly do manual labor or execute skilled trades.

Since at smallest the commencement of my career, application engineers have been considered white-collar. We activity in offices at computers, and we agreement alongside knowledge. Our activity requires advanced training or education.

But what if that assumption has been incorrect? What if we were really blue-collar, skilled tradespeople all along?

Typically, whenever we think of blue-collar workers, we think of group who do the hands-on labor of making or fixing stuff. Builders, plumbers, carpenters, electricians, miners, care engineers, storage workers etc. Software developers have typically divided themselves from this category, but I’m not entirely certain why. We do the identical item — that is, we create or fix material — apart from we activity in bits fairly than atoms.

This is entirely not to say that application developers aren’t as skilled as we idea we were. If anything, I’d say categorising betterment as a skilled commerce gives additional credit to the activity we do. Just akin electricians or carpenters, application developers must expend years practicing their accomplishment in command to rotate into skilled and sought-after. It doesn’t necessarily necessitate a ceremonial education, but it certainly takes period and custom to master.

I amazement whether this incorrect assumption is fuelling, at smallest in part, the current AI character emergency that application developers are facing. Blue-collar workers, in general, have successfully ridden the waves of scientific change. If you can oversee a squad of manual carpenters, you can additionally oversee a storage complete of woodworking robots. It’s normally the white-collar workers who withstand the most financial disruption from important scientific innovations.

Software engineers are discovering that, fair akin anyone alternatively in a skilled trade, they really can be outpaced by technology. So we do what another skilled traders have done: fig out how to use the new innovation to do the jobs we used to do by hand.

I’m fearful that this is the end of a extremely lengthy honeymoon for application developers. We have spent the former 30 years being treated akin rock stars in our companies. Our period and notice is protected at all costs; we have been capable to petition salaries which far outpace our peers; non-technical colleagues accept everything we say concerning how lengthy things obtain or how difficult it’s going to be to compose features. But the honeymoon is over, and we’re all freaking out because, among another things, we are no longer the most crucial individual in the company.

We are the seamstresses lamenting the introduction of the loom. We are the lumberjacks worrying concerning chainsaws. We’re the accountants panicking concerning being replaced by Excel.

But if we study how to use the looms, the spreadsheets, and the chainsaws, we power fair be okay. And the fine news is that there are motionless group sewing and chopping timber by hand, since they desire to. It may no longer be item you can get paid for, but it’s certainly item you can continue to enjoy.

Other Article Hacker News
↑
Close Right Ads
Close Left Ads