DOJ Asks Court To Reinstate Charges Against Mistakenly Deported Man Kilmar Abrego Garcia

Aug 18, 2026 04:15 PM - 1 hour ago 2

Topline

The Justice Department connected Monday urged a national appellate tribunal to reinstate criminal charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia—who was mistakenly deported to El Salvador by the Trump management past year—three months aft a national judge dismissed quality smuggling charges brought against him.

Kilmar Abrego Garcia arrives for his first check-in astatine the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Baltimore Field Office the time aft a national judge ordered his merchandise from a detention successful Pennsylvania.

Getty Images

Key Facts

In a filing made earlier the Sixth Circuit appeals court, the DOJ claimed the authorities had clear “probable origin and aggregate morganatic bases to prosecute” Abrego Garcia and based on that the earlier ruling relied connected “dubious assumptions” to driblet the charges.

In his ruling that dropped the charges successful May, Tennessee national judge Waverly Crenshaw noted that the lawsuit reflected an “abuse of prosecuting power” and “vindictive motive” owed to Abrego Garcia's suit challenging his deportation to El Salvador.

The latest filing based on that the DOJ reopened a criminal probe into Abrego Garcia aft courts ordered his return to the state that it “previously closed pursuing his removal,” and the quality smuggling indictment was brought based connected “new evidence.”

The filing besides based on that acting U.S. Attorney Robert McGuire brought the lawsuit against Abrego Garcia based connected a probe triggered by a 2022 postulation stop, and that he “himself had nary liking successful Abrego’s removal suit.”

The DOJ based on that the quality smuggling charges were brought against Abrego Garcia owed to morganatic concerns astir his return to the state aft a tribunal reversed his deportation.

In the filing, the Justice Department urged the appeals tribunal to reverse the Tennessee national judge’s ruling dismissing criminal charges against Abrego Garcia.

What Had The Tennessee Federal Judge Said In His Ruling?

“The grounds earlier this Court sadly reflects an maltreatment of prosecuting power. The Court does not scope its conclusion lightly. The nonsubjective grounds present shows that, absent Abrego’s successful suit challenging his removal to El Salvador, the Government would not person brought this prosecution. The Executive Branch closed its investigation connected the November 2022 postulation stop. Only aft Abrego succeeded successful vindicating his authorities did the Executive Branch reopen that investigation,” Crenshaw had said successful his ruling.

More