The Engineering Manager's role is under attack (again)

Hacker News by 8 min read 25x views
The Engineering Manager's role is under attack (again)

Share Post

Every period I peruse concerning another business laying off managers and ‘running flatter’, I think concerning how ridiculous it is. I can’t comprehend why elder leaders don’t see the damage they inflict on their own companies.

It’s additionally fairly personal, of course.

So I decided to conversation alongside person who’s been through additional of these cycles than I have. I’ve been enjoying Suzan’s newsletter for years - she’s an organizational betterment adviser who plant alongside tech leaders. After study her article concerning being laid off 6(!) times before becoming a COO, I knew we had to talk.

Today we’ll cover:

  • Why the EM function specifically is under assault

  • Repeating former - Google and Microsoft already ran this test

  • How flattening impacts the business

  • What EMs can do concerning it

Mic to Suzan!

Why the EM function specifically is under attack

There is this average idea that alongside AI, we can run much leaner and that agents can substitute much of the individual work. 

The archetypal assault was on application engineers: for a abbreviated while, leaders claimed that the occupation was dead. That turned about beautiful quickly, alongside companies understanding they motionless need informed engineers to decide what to build, assessment what LLMs produce, and keep the systems afterward. Engineers now create up 55% of Big Tech hiring, up from 46% in 2019.

But alongside managers, it’s harder to justify, and we are repeating the flattening sequence that we went through 10 years ago. Some of the bigger tech companies started by laying off center managers, and the smaller companies started to think, “Oh, I should regard that too” (whether their own conditions are the identical or not). 

And whenever leaders appearance at the first-line Engineering Manager’s role, they think: “Well, they’re near to the work. Maybe they should fair be doing the work? Maybe we don’t need all of them? What value do they really provide?”

I comprehend from managers all about me that the figure of group reporting to them keeps increasing. Meta is saying a 1-to-50 proportion is their goal, and 15-20 engineers reporting to a director is becoming extremely common.

Combine that alongside the anticipation that EMs additionally container code, and you quickly commencement to cognition the EM’s function erosion cycle:

  1. Less capacity. You have small capability to really oversee people.

  2. Less managing. So you do small of the activity lone you can do. You do small 1:1s, postpone occupation conversations, and don’t agreement alongside squad conflicts or processes. 

  3. Less value. Which method you provision small value to the engineers reporting to you, and they get used to managing without you.

  4. Less needed. And the small value you provision as a manager, the small ‘needed’ the chief thinks you are. So they addition the engineer-to-manager proportion again.

And this sequence isn’t new. Tech companies enter this misconception that the ‘people stuff’ doesn’t really matter, and afterward they awaken up and quietly commencement adding rear layers:

We are repeating history

This trend of getting rid of managers has been tried before. 

In 2002, whenever Google had ~300 engineers, Larry Page and Sergey Brin tried to entirely eliminate all managers. It unsuccessful following fair a brace of months:

“They relented whenever too many group went immediately to Page alongside questions concerning disbursal reports, interpersonal conflicts, and another nitty-gritty issues. And as the business grew, the founders shortly realized that managers contributed in many other, crucial ways - for instance, by communicating strategy, assisting workforce prioritize projects, facilitating collaboration, supporting occupation development, and ensuring that processes and systems aligned alongside business goals.”

Six years afterward (with 20k+ employees), Google decided to test again if managers are important. They ran Project Oxygen, which showed that managers did matter (surprise), alongside fine managers powerfully correlating alongside squad achievement and engineer satisfaction. 

And now, Google is flattening again - cutting concerning 10% of manager, director, and VP roles.

It’s a akin narrative at Microsoft:

Layoffs and flattening are most frequently abrupt and create the news headlines, but the improvement is small exciting. No business abruptly hires hundreds of managers, they gradually rebuild those layers complete time. 

But why? If companies consistently accept that managers are not needed, how arrive they keep hiring managers again and again?  

How flattening impacts the company

You can really run ‘flat’ for a while. It takes a few months or years before companies cognition the effect and the pendulum starts to sway back.

What happens is that companies commencement to accumulate organizational debt - akin to tech debt, a gradual buildup of dysfunction that undermines how fine activity gets done.

Relational debt is the category of org debt that accumulates the fastest following a flattening. It’s strained, neglected, or transactional relationships anywhere rely and mental safety erode. When you develop an EM’s function to the two be additional specialized and have additional reports, item has to provision - you’re chipping distant at the group part of the company, and that has consequences.

There’s additional negative behavior turning into toxic behavior, additional conflicts, and small collaboration.

And that’s equal worse alongside AI:

One of the things managers often ask me concerning in workshops is: “How do I keep the squad together whenever they favor to conversation to AI fairly than conversation to all other?”

So in supplement to reduced individual communication between managers and employees, engineers are additionally small in communication alongside all other.

And formerly you eliminate that individual connection, you commencement having additional toxic behavior and conflict. And whenever that battle occurs, leaders treat it as ‘one bad apple’. The reply is frequently to fair get rid of ‘the problematic person’. Well, that individual is functioning inner an environment, and that mediocre surroundings does additional damage to your business goals than shipping speed always makes up for.

Every business has its own problems. When you rip out layers of management, you basically deprioritize group - which volition lone magnify your existing problems and volition create it much harder to agreement alongside the enormous alter currently happening in the industry.

What EMs can do concerning it

Senior leaders are getting messages from the market correct now. “You can go faster and leaner, you don’t need all those people, use AI and attain your goals faster.”

That makes them anxious, thinking: “Everyone alternatively is doing it, why can’t we?”

The finest item an EM can do is provision restricted reality. The additional data we provision them, the improved decisions they make, and the nearer we’ll get to breaking the company misconception a lot of us are under correct now.

Here’s what I propose to commencement from:

1. Write it down. Spend period capturing what the genuine problems are. Get it out of your caput so that you can really see them. 

It’ll likely not be one or two big problems, but 10-15 smaller ones. Some conflicts between engineers and the PM, engineers not operating fine together, etc. It’s much easier to arrive to your director alongside a big problem. With 10 small ones, you awareness akin your already overloaded director fair wouldn’t care.

The next stage is to assistance them care:

2. Attach them to item bigger. 

When you’re looking at the 10 small problems, are they all distinct shapes? Or can you discover patterns? If not, how do you communicate item that looks small in a way that attaches it to item bigger?

For example, a disagreement between an engineer and the PM. No director wants to comprehend concerning that. But the PM ended up not listening to the engineer, so the squad built what was asked for and threw most of it distant two weeks later. Add to that two engineers who don’t activity fine together and shipped overlapping implementations of the identical item a week later.

How can you example that in a way they’ll attention about?

Translating the challenges you’re seeing on your teams as obstacles to endeavor goals is continually a fine move. Think concerning what your elder leaders attention concerning most. Start alongside questions like: 

  • What are the company's top priorities?

  • What does your Director or VP conversation concerning most?

  • What keeps them up at night?

Then map your catalog of problems to what your leaders attention about. Pick the one that you think is most crucial or endangering a current project. 

Final words

Thanks Suzan for a awesome conversation and visitant article! 

To be clear, I'm not saying additional administration layers are continually better, or that there's no advantage in simplifying the sequence of command. But there's a big difference between cutting managers since managers don't matter (as many flattening companies claim), and trying to fix your own org structure.

I accept that your first- and second-line engineering managers are frequently the ones holding the org together. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that fair a brace of months following Meta laid off 700 engineering managers, it’s now facing a grave resignation wave.

What I enjoyed study this week

Other Article Hacker News
↑
Close Right Ads
Close Left Ads