Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.
Key Takeaways
- Franchisee profitability is the strongest indicator of a franchise brand’s health. Forward-thinking franchisors comprehend that not all growth is equal, and income solitary lone tells one flank of the story.
- Franchisors frequently deficiency comparable unit-level financial data since disbursal data is decentralized and inconsistent.
- This creates a profitability blind place that hides underperformance, makes benchmarking unreliable and makes it difficult to provision productive coaching.
- A Point-of-Profit scheme can normalize the operational P&L, enabling consistency, trustworthy benchmarks and improved direction for operators.
A key metric for a franchise brand’s health is how profitable the franchisees in the scheme are. Sales growth and component economics are additionally key indicators, but owner profitability mostly determines whether the brand volition succeed. Forward-thinking franchisors comprehend that not all growth is created equal, and that income solitary lone tells one flank of the story.
Franchisees can article record-breaking revenue and motionless not rotate a profit. Left unchecked, this can guide to closures and slower expansion, equal whenever the numbers appearance fine on paper. The inverse is true whenever franchisees are profitable. They add stability to the scheme by reinvesting in the brand, referring prospects and, in the best-case scenario, becoming multi-unit operators themselves.
But at the franchise scheme level, how can franchisors decide gain at the component level?
Sure, financial statements can provision a awareness of how a component is performing. Yet, informed franchisors cognize that using them to measure unit-level achievement is akin comparing apples to oranges. At best, franchisors h2o downward their Item 19 statements, hurting their rivalrous position. So, if franchisee profitability is critical to the brand’s achievement and health, why do franchisors run blindly?
Uncovering the profitability blind spot
The issue alongside understanding profitability at the component flat is that you need comparable data to decide achievement throughout locations. While franchisors have admission to standardized revenue data, the identical doesn’t use to the disbursal and gain flank of the equation.
Unlike revenue data, which consistently runs through a centralized POS system, disbursal data is decentralized. The raw data comes from multiple sources: banks, payroll systems, credit cards, suppliers, fee platforms, etc. When it comes in, missing data makes it difficult to categorize the expense.
Banks, for example, frequently provision cryptic transaction descriptions. Descriptions are short, and the identical types of transactions and vendors can appear alternatively throughout banks. The bookkeeper at the component flat must decipher and categorize those expenses using their finest judgment.
Additionally, the accounting care of taxes, insurance, tips, payroll, owner’s compensation and another expenses is frequently open to lawful differences in recording. Which accounts are recorded on a prosperity basis, and which are accumulated using several method? Did the accountant really execute a complete financial institution reconciliation following the period?
While there is plentifulness of sub-standard bookkeeping done, that isn’t the biggest issue. The item is that it’s invariably inconsistent, and that is what blinds the franchisor.
The downstream effect of inconsistent data
Without a standardized example for disbursal data, benchmarking throughout the scheme to comprehend the drivers rearward unit-level profitability is unreliable. It makes evaluating related achievement throughout operators difficult and compounds the complexity of coaching franchisees to enhance component profitability.
Without apples-to-apples data, no one can rely what they’re looking at. That’s how underperforming locations can fly under the radar until months later, whenever the numbers commencement artwork a distinct picture. Is that the finest franchisors can do?
Solving the base logic of the problem
As an industry, all franchisors have a “brand chart-of-accounts,” which they anticipate all franchisees to use. Easier stated than practically implemented, maintained and controlled. Even alongside component differences in bookkeeping inside the brand standard, mapping from one to the another is tedious and error-prone. Most franchisors hence study a dismal compliance charge — equal at this level.
Mapping additionally doesn’t document for whether a unit’s books are closed or reconciled and whether the disbursal has been consistently categorized in the financial statement. One resolution is to create a mandated Point-of-Profit system, akin to a POS on the revenue side.
The Point-of-Profit scheme doesn’t substitute the local bookkeeper or create all the detailed financial statements the owner volition need. Instead, its intent is to normalize the operational P&L, enabling consistency, trustworthy benchmarks and improved direction for operators.
After a simple, one-time setup by the franchisee, raw transactions from banks and credit cards, affirmative accordant data from the POS and payroll system, stream through an AI or automation resolution built on franchise-specific accounting rules and norms. This method helps justify consistency at the transaction and document level.
The key is not to aim for perfection throughout the system. The goal is to treat origin data consistently throughout locations, enabling apples-to-apples comparisons that, whenever paired alongside POS data, empower endeavor coaches to do their jobs additional efficiently and provision franchisors a clearer image of scheme health.
All boats increase whenever the concentration is on profitability
The premise of a franchise is that everyone in the scheme wins through consistency and leverage, but franchisors and franchisees can’t win together without comparable unit-level data to decide franchisee profitability.
When financial data is spotless and reliable, betterment teams get additional dependable data to develop the system, franchisees get improved assistance from endeavor coaches and a clearer perspective of their achievement against their equal segment, and the norm of Item 19 in the FDD becomes defensible.
