How to report PPC performance without lying to yourself (or your boss)

Early successful my career, I was responsible for reporting metrics for a company’s homepage. A personnel of the usability squad wanted to cognize really overmuch postulation a peculiar widget was getting. When we pulled the numbers, the consequence was underwhelming: About 2.5% of visitors really utilized it.

But that’s not the number that ended up successful the report. Instead, the widget’s usage was reframed arsenic “a mates 1000 visits per month.” That was technically true. It besides told a wholly different communicative from 2.5%.

That infinitesimal taught maine thing I’ve carried passim my paid hunt career: Data isn’t achromatic and white, and the personification presenting it has a work to show an meticulous story, not conscionable a flattering one.

Data doesn’t lie, but PPC practitioners sometimes do. In PPC, we person much opportunities to blur that statement than astir group realize. Here’s wherever it happens and really to make judge your reporting holds up truthful you enactment honorable and ethical.

Conversions aren’t conscionable conversions

If there’s 1 number that gets flattened astir often successful paid hunt reporting, it’s conversions.

A “conversion” tin mean thing wholly different depending connected what’s really being counted. A shape capable isn’t a trading qualified lead (MQL). An MQL isn’t a sale.

For example, a telephone call, a chat initiation, and a personification watching 50% of a video are each conversion actions I’ve seen tracked successful the aforesaid account, sometimes rolled into the aforesaid header number and reported arsenic “conversions.”

When you show a customer aliases stakeholder, “We sewage an fantabulous number of conversions,” without specifying what that conversion really was, that’s not reporting. That’s editorializing, and it’s not a coagulated instauration for PPC strategy decisions.

Before you coming a conversion number, inquire yourself:

• What action is really being counted? A shape fill, a call, a chat, a video view, aliases a purchase?
• How acold is that action from an existent business outcome? A lead and a closed waste aren’t the aforesaid type of win.
• Would the personification reference this study make a different determination if they knew what was down the number?

If the reply to the 3rd mobility is yes, you beryllium them that context, and you should see it erstwhile you present the report.

Your CTR benchmark is astir apt a decade retired of date

I still perceive practitioners opportunity a run is performing good because its click-through complaint is “over 2%.” That benchmark comes from an era of PPC that doesn’t beryllium anymore.

Today’s bidding algorithms are acold much blase astatine uncovering users who lucifer your existing converters. That unsocial pushes click-through complaint (CTR) up crossed the board, independent of thing you did strategically.

A 2% CTR benchmark from 10 years agone tells you almost thing astir whether a modern, algorithmically targeted run is really patient and gathering its goals.

Reporting that “CTR is supra benchmark” without acknowledging what’s driving that lift, whether it’s amended targeting, amended creative, aliases simply a much tin algorithm uncovering easier audiences, is different measurement information gets presented arsenic bully news without earning that designation.

I don’t deliberation there’s a morganatic cosmopolitan benchmark near to constituent to. The algorithm has gotten excessively bully astatine uncovering easy clicks for a azygous number to mean the aforesaid point crossed accounts, industries, aliases moreover campaigns wrong the aforesaid account.

Stakeholders will ever inquire the basal question: “Are these numbers bully aliases bad?”

As taxable matter experts, our occupation isn’t to manus them a bequest benchmark to cheque off, particularly 1 that doesn’t really beryllium successful immoderate meaningful form.

True expertise intends redefining occurrence and shifting the speech distant from vanity metrics that the algorithm inflates for us. It intends anchoring our reports successful the business outcomes we were hired to drive.

It’s besides important to explicate really modern bid strategies impact the metrics you’re reporting.

Dig deeper: Why a little CTR tin beryllium amended for your PPC campaigns

Raw numbers and percentages show different stories — usage both

The widget communicative I opened pinch is really a communicative astir earthy numbers versus percentages, and that aforesaid hostility shows up perpetually successful paid hunt reporting.

When you’re breaking down conversions by type, for example, showing that telephone calls dress up 40% of conversions versus leads astatine 60% tells a very different communicative than saying “142 calls, 213 leads.” Neither type is wrong. But presenting only 1 of them, particularly the 1 that happens to look better, is simply a choice. It isn’t neutral reporting.

It’s thing we person to beryllium conscious of whenever we coming data.

The hole isn’t complicated: Show the information successful much than 1 way.

By presenting earthy counts and percentages together, you springiness whoever sounds the study capable discourse to understand what really happened, alternatively of what you want them to return distant from the report. Percentages adhd discourse to the data.

---

What you take to attraction connected successful a study is itself a shape of manipulation

This benignant of manipulation by omission is thing I deliberation astir about often because I’ve seen it costs advertisers existent money and create confusion.

For example, I erstwhile took complete an relationship from different practitioner who had been telling the business that its debased costs per click (CPC) was a motion of success.

If a debased CPC were really the goal, it’d beryllium easy to deed that number by moving everything done the Display Network aliases different upper-funnel campaign. But that run type whitethorn not align pinch what the marque really needs.

In my example, because the business had been told for months that a debased CPC meant bully performance, it had bought into the incorrect metric entirely.

In reality, a higher CPC often drives amended business outcomes and tin moreover consequence successful a little costs per acquisition because you’re paying much to scope higher-intent, higher-value users alternatively of optimizing for inexpensive clicks that don’t convert. For my client, that turned retired to beryllium true.

Focusing a stakeholder’s attraction connected the metric that makes your activity look champion alternatively of the 1 that reflects their existent goals is 1 of the quietest ways information gets weaponized successful this industry. We should beryllium client-first erstwhile it comes to reporting data.

Attribution tin hide whether your walk is doing thing astatine all

Even meticulous reporting connected conversions, CTR, and CPC tin still disguise a bigger question: Would those conversions person happened anyway?

Attribution models springiness in installments for conversions crossed touchpoints, but it’s important to retrieve that in installments isn’t causation. A branded hunt run tin show a immense measurement of “conversions” that would’ve happened done integrated aliases nonstop traffic, sloppy of whether the advertisement ever ran. The study looks great, but the incremental business effect whitethorn beryllium adjacent to zero.

This doesn’t mean we wouldn’t tally a marque campaign. It intends the information needs much discourse and nuance.

Incrementality testing — whether that’s utilizing a holdout group, moving a geo experiment, aliases conducting a conversion assistance study — is the only existent measurement to reply whether your media walk is creating caller business aliases simply claiming in installments for outcomes that would’ve happened anyway.

Reporting conversion measurement without ever addressing incrementality is 1 of the astir communal and astir defensible-sounding ways paid hunt information tells an incomplete story.

Dig deeper: Why your B2B PPC metrics whitethorn beryllium lying to you

3 manipulation strategies worthy naming directly

Most of the metric issues supra hap without anyone intending to mislead. But a fewer circumstantial patterns are worthy calling retired because erstwhile you spot them, you can’t unsee them successful your ain reporting.

• Conversion stacking: Counting aggregate actions from a azygous personification travel — say, a chat, past a call, past a shape capable from the aforesaid personification — arsenic 3 abstracted wins alternatively of one.
• Cherry-picked day ranges: Comparing this period to a deliberately slow period past quarter, aliases softly excluding the week your relationship had an outage aliases search issue. A day scope chosen against a anemic baseline tin make almost immoderate relationship look for illustration it’s improving.
• Vanity metric substitution: Leading pinch a metric that looks bully — possibly impressions, clicks, aliases “reach” – erstwhile the metric that really matters — qualified leads, revenue, aliases CPA – tells a little flattering story.

I’m not saying each practitioner who uses these patterns is acting successful bad faith. Most of the time, it’s habit, not deception. But habits are precisely what request to beryllium questioned if we’re superior astir reporting information honestly.

Paid hunt doesn’t person a governing board. That’s precisely why this matters

Unlike galore licensed professions, paid hunt practitioners don’t reply to a regulatory body. We person level certifications, not an morals board. That intends the modular for really honestly we coming information to clients and stakeholders is mostly self-imposed.

I don’t deliberation that gets talked astir capable successful our industry. It’s easy to framework a number successful the champion imaginable light, particularly erstwhile your occupation information aliases a customer narration depends connected the communicative that number tells.

But contextualizing conversions accurately, utilizing existent benchmarks, showing some earthy numbers and percentages, and focusing connected the metrics that really bespeak business outcomes isn’t conscionable bully practice. It’s the ethical baseline for PPC.

If we don’t clasp ourselves to that standard, nary 1 other will.