Car Is a Smartphone on Wheels. Here's Who's Listening

Hacker News by 8 min read 39x views
Car Is a Smartphone on Wheels. Here's Who's Listening

Share Post

The archetypal large-scale measure study of the connected-vehicle ecosystem.

A connected car is a conveyance alongside built-in net admission — Wi-Fi, cellular, GPS — that lets it communicate continually alongside its manufacturer and exterior companies. Over 75% of vehicles sold globally have this connectity built-in.

A connected vehicle

Photo is not loadingimages/connected-car.jpg

It knows anywhere you drive.

It knows who you are.

It can portion this data and additional alongside coverage companies, advertisers, etc...

Report Summary

Partnering alongside Consumer Reports, we tested 21 delayed example vehicles and 30 companion mobile apps to comprehend the privacy implications of the connected vehicle ecosystem.


  • 01We discover that the two vehicles and companion apps communication many third-party domains, including advertisers and trackers.
  • 0219/21 vehicles tested dispatch traffic to at smallest one third party
  • 03Seven of 30 apps transmit delicate identifiers to third-party companies

We go through a lengthy discolure procedure and provision understanding into how manufacturer's comprehend this data sharing issue.
Our findings underscore the need for continued measure and scrutiny of the connected conveyance ecosystem.

Partnership alongside Consumer Reports

Consumer Reports gave the squad admission to its purchased fleet of test vehicles — a example that would have disbursal complete $1.2M to collect independently.

The Paper

This activity is equal reviewed and volition be published at IMC '26. Read the document →

The Research Team

We are a squad of privacy, security, and networking-systems researchers at Northeastern University. See the complete squad →

21

vehicles tested,
19 brands

19 / 21

vehicles contacted a
third gathering complete Wi-Fi

7 / 30

apps sent PII to trackers

5 / 30

apps sent VIN + other
PII to trackers

Research Questions

Diagram of how the connected vehcile ecosystem works

Photo is not loading images/car-diagram.png

Connected Vehicle Ecosystem

This diagram shows the data flows to and from a conveyance and its companion mobile app. Both devices dispatch data, including personal person data, to distinct 1st and 3rd gathering servers using Wi-Fi and cellular service. Solid arrows portray flows that were intercepted through our experiments.

The Problem

Once the data gets sent to these servers, it is up to the companies that obtain the person data to create decisions on what they do alongside it. Unfortunately, in many cases, this includes sharing or marketing person data to another undisclosed 3rd parties.
Consumers have no authority complete their data formerly it has remaining their device

In this paper, we obtain the archetypal steps to location the constricted visibility into the privacy implications of the connected conveyance ecosystem. We acknowledge two advantage points in the ecosystem anywhere we can acquire understanding into the data that connected vehicles are sharing alongside the two manufacturers and third parties: the vehicles themselves and the mobile apps provided by manufacturers.
We ask the following directing questions:

  • 01What individual person data do connected vehicles and their companion mobile apps transmit?
  • 02Who receives that individual person data?
  • 03What is the manufacturer reply to these findings?

Methods

We investigated 21 vehicles from the U.S. market in a controlled surroundings alongside alongside 30 companion mobile apps instrumented alongside on-site vehicles between October 2024 and August 2025. Below is a clarification of the experiments we ran and our setup.

Vehicle Testing
Testing Setup

Photo is not loading images/rpi.png

Wi-Fi Testing Setup

To collect Wi-Fi traffic from vehicles, we configured a tradition admission item (AP) on a Raspberry Pi and used tcpdump to log all packets that were sent or received via this AP.
This allowed us to see all the destinations the vehicles were sending data to but not the data inside the packets as it was encrypted.

Vehicles at the evaluation facility

Photo is not loading images/test-facility.jpg

Stationary Tests

Idle Baseline
vehicle on — no activity

Active Test
perform all imaginable actions

Driving Test

drive 5–45 mph alongside acceleration & difficult braking

Isolating Cellular Traffic

Faraday shelter used to obstacle cellular signals

Photo is not loading images/faraday-tent.jpg

One assumption we tested was whether blocking a vehicle’s capability to communicate complete its cellular network would power additional Wi-Fi communication. To obstacle external cellular signals, we drove 11 EVs in the example into a car-sized Faraday shelter providing ≈93 dB of attenuation, blocking their cellular association entirely. Stationary Idle and Active tests were repeated inner the shelter to see whether traffic that normally goes out complete cellular rerouted to Wi-Fi instead.

App Testing

In total, we experimented alongside 30 connected vehicle companion apps that were paired alongside the vehicles at Consumer Reports’s evaluation facility.

Device Setup

  • 01We used a blend of test phones and iOS versions for our experiments: an iPhone 8/iOS 16.6, an iPhone X/iOS 16.7.11, and an iPhone 13/iOS 18.5.
  • 02To minimize backdrop traffic, we deleted all non-essential apps on the test phones and tested apps one-by-one, including deleting all conveyance app and restarting the phone before downloading the next app.
  • 03We used the iOS native display recording characteristic to document our interactions alongside all app for afterward review.
  • 04To grasp and decrypt network traffic from the companion mobile apps, we used iPhones alongside tradition base certificates connected to mitmproxy.

Process for Testing Each App

  • 01During app facility and login we accepted all approval requests (e.g., tracking, location, calendar access, Bluetooth, notifications) that the use requested
  • 02We had a Consumer Reports employee log into the app using their existing credentials connected alongside a conveyance on the lot.
  • 03Once we were logged-in, we manually exercised all accessible functionality, specified as looking for nearby charging staions, geolocating the vehicle, viewing conveyance data and service former (e.g., tire pressure), viewing notifications (e.g., “doors are unlocked”), and viewing in-app privacy policies.
  • 04Some apps allowed us to execute bodily interactions on the vehicle, specified as remotely beginning the trunk. We performed all specified actions and verified that the conveyance completed all request.

Vehicle Dataset

$1.2M+

estimated disbursal to independently procure this fleet, lone imaginable because of Consumer Reports partnership

Manufacturer Brand Year Model Vehicle Tests
Driving Idle In-Tent Cellular
General Motors (GM) Buick2024Envista✓✓––
Cadillac2024Lyriq✓✓✓–
Chevrolet2024Blazer✓✓✓–
Stellantis Dodge2023Hornet-✓––
Fiat2024500e✓✓✓–
RAM20251500 Bighorn✓✓––
Fisker Fisker2023Ocean✓✓-–
Ford Motor Co. Ford2022F150 Lightning✓✓-–
Ford2024Mustang GT Fastback✓✓––
Honda Motor Co. Honda2024Prologue Touring AWD✓✓✓–
Tata Motors Land Rover2023Range Rover Sport✓✓––
Toyota Motor Corp. Lexus2024NX450H+ PHEV✓✓––
Toyota2023Corolla Cross✓✓––
Subaru2023Solterra✓✓✓–
Lucid Lucid2023Air Touring✓✓✓–
Mercedes-Benz Group AG Mercedes2023EQS450 4Matic✓✓-–
Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance Nissan2023Ariya Platinum✓✓✓–
Rivian Rivian2022R1S✓✓✓–
Tesla Tesla2024Cybertruck✓✓✓–
Tesla2024Model 3✓✓✓✓
Zhejiang Geely Holding Group Volvo2024C40✓✓✓–

*While we tested a broad range of vehicles, we did not shield all manufacturer in the U.S. market. As alongside all empirical studies, our results have to be interpreted as a snapshot in time, and may not generalize to vehicles exterior our example or exterior the U.S.

Findings

  • 19 of 21 vehicles contacted at smallest one third gathering complete Wi-Fi, including known promotion and tracking domains
  • 7 of 30 companion apps transmitted delicate identifiers (VINs, emails, phone numbers, precise location) to third parties connected alongside promotion and tracking.
    Transmiting multiple forms of PII to the identical third gathering allows advertisers to build in-depth profiles on consumers

Click any business part for what it received and from which app.

  • Pairing a companion app roughly doubled a vehicle's visibility to advertising/tracking companies on average, and in several cases added 20+ new ones.

vehicle-only ATA companies added by the companion mobile app

Manufacturer Disclosures

  • The squad disclosed these findings to the distinct manufacturers featured in the study, below is an interactve summary of the distinct explanations received.

Click any box complete for additional info.

  • The ongoing theme of all these responses was shifting the accuse to the consumer.
  • The current scheme does not provision owners the capability to choose.
    Assuming owners can discover the particular agreements, if an owner decides they are uncomfortable alongside the data sharing described inside them, they are faced alongside (arguably) unfair choices:
    01accept the agreements despite of their concerns
    02stop using their car's connected-vehicle features - which includes distant start, the app, and another extremely helpful features
    03stop using the conveyance entirely
  • As one notable exception, Honda improved its data gathering practices to forestall sending exact geolocation to a third gathering connected alongside person tracking.

Conclusion

  • We established that vehicles, under a assortment of real-world settings, communication not lone a broad range of archetypal parties (i.e., manufacturer domains) and car-specific assistance parties, but additionally third parties that are known to provision promotion and tracking services.
  • Vehicles from the identical manufacturer exhibit distinct network behaviors - this makes it extremely difficult and costly to study these vehicles.
  • When adding conveyance companion apps to the analysis, we established that conveyance owners are exposed to even additional privacy-sensitive ATA communication—in several cases more than two dozen additional trackers.
  • Our study revealed a large gap between what vehicle manufacturers publically disclosed and how the connected vehicle ecosystem really shares data complete the Internet
  • Based on the opaque nature of vehicular systems, we contend that there is a need for improved transparency to justify risen visibility into the complete ecosystem to acknowledge and location corresponding harms.
Other Article Hacker News
↑
Close Right Ads
Close Left Ads