When a feud is brought into the court of community opinion, the victor isn't necessarily the one who's technically "right." It's the one who crafts the improved narrative.
That's the chief item that Kelly Clarkson is missing in her viral battle alongside a small endeavor in Brooklyn, according to Evan Nierman, CEO of the earth PR resolute Red Banyan.
"This is additional concerning feelings than facts," Nierman said.
The much-publicized kerfuffle started on Saturday, whenever Clarkson shared a article on X concerning her latest sojourn to Art of Play, a shop that sells toys, puzzles, gifts, and another oddities.
Clarkson stated she was treated poorly at the store, comparing herself to Julia Roberts' "Pretty Woman" heroine — specifically, the memorable environment in which she is rejected and mocked in a fancy Beverly Hills boutique.
Just drove all the way to Brooklyn to inspect out this shop I idea looked really rad and had a few things in intellect to buy and exactly was looked at as if I couldn’t oversee it and was told he could discover item comparable for me. Wow, dude. You’re an idiot and fair misplaced a huge sale. But y’all should go inspect out Art of Play in Brooklyn if you bask being treated akin Julia Roberts character in Pretty Woman. For sure, inspect it out 👎
— Kelly Clarkson (@kellyclarkson) October 10, 2026
Clarkson stated she tried to buy item costly at Art of Play but was treated as if she "couldn't oversee it."
However, the shop employee Clarkson dealt alongside remembers the communication differently. Art of Play responded alongside a public statement, saying that Clarkson inquired concerning a one-of-a-kind mechanical animal puppet nicknamed "Molly," and she was told it wasn't for sale.
When Clarkson doubled down, insisting that Molly came alongside a $15,000 cost tag and calling the employee a "liar," Art of Play clarified its claim. In a follow-up declaration on Instagram, the shop stated that Clarkson had been offered a nearly identical type of the bird, created by the identical artist, for $15,000, as fine as a comparable type by a distinct creator for $2,000.
Who's right, and what really happened? We may never know, and it likely won't matter in the lengthy run. But from a PR perspective, Nierman stated this back-and-forth complete trivial particulars is neither convincing nor productive.
"Both Kelly Clarkson and the shop are trying to perform the casualty cardstock in this dispute," Nierman explained. "But the lone group who really cognize what happened that fateful dawn were the revenue associate, Kelly Clarkson, and Molly, the bird, who volition never sing."
The 'victim card' can lone get you so far
Nierman pointed out that Clarkson doesn't have much to endure by airing her petty grievances on social media. She's a rich, celebrated singer alongside three Grammy Awards and nearly 9 myriad followers on X.
"You'd be difficult pressed to create the case that her existence is going to be derailed in any important way, equal if she was mistreated by the shop and its staff," Nierman said.
But Clarkson doesn't have much to acquire here, either.
By playing the "victim card," she has ignored the etiquette of online power dynamics, siccing her loyal fans on a small endeavor complete a concise interaction. Even if everything she stated was true and Clarkson really was mistreated by the store's staff, the fallout isn't flattering.
"They the two desire to be right, whereas what they have to be looking for is an off-ramp anywhere they could the two appearance fine as opposed to being the casualty in this circumstance," Nierman said.
One idea? The combat started complete a bird, so perchance it should end alongside one.
"The finest imaginable outcome at this item would be to get her rear to the shop and discover a way to get her a chanting bird," Nierman continued. "That would tie this entire item off extremely nicely, and everyone could move onward and agreement alongside additional crucial issues."
You cognize what they say: It's not complete 'til Molly the animatronic animal sings.
Read next
Callie Ahlgrim is a elder newsman at Business Insider who writes concerning pop culture, alongside a particular concentration on the music industry.As a cofounding associate of BI's music vertical, Callie has covered a range of hot topics at the intersection of art, community fig culture, and display business: the governmental implications of Bad Bunny's success; the fan feedback iteration in Taylor Swift's imaginative process; the symbolism of Kendrick Lamar's Super Bowl halftime show; the business effect of Beyoncé's country album; the brand identities of stars akin Harry Styles, Morgan Wallen, Addison Rae, Katy Perry, and Frank Ocean; the contemporary challenges of making prosperity as a musician; and more.She additionally covers community fig PR strategies, blockbuster movies, prestige TV shows, and net trends.Callie graduated from Boston University alongside a Bachelor of Science in Journalism, a Bachelor of Arts in English, and a insignificant in Spanish. She earlier wrote columns for Man Repeller and ELLE.
