A nurse was sued by her student-loan company. After losing a chunk of her paycheck, here's how it turned out.

It's been complete a twelvemonth since Hannah Bates, 31, was sued by her personal student-loan lender — a lawful battle she called lengthy, expensive, and confusing.

It started in October 2024, whenever Sallie Mae notified her that she'd made the final payment on her outstanding balance of $55,000. Bates knew that was a mistake. In fact, she was falling rearward on her $1,500 monthly payments and had years' value left. When she tried to explain alongside Sallie Mae, she stated she received conflicting data on how to evade default. Six months later, Sallie Mae sued her to collect.

When she's not operating her 12-hour nursing shifts, Bates has represented herself in the lawsuit, alongside the assistance of ChatGPT. She stated it's taken a important affectional and financial toll, and following multiple unsuccessful attempts to attain a fee agreement, the court ordered that her wages be garnished.

She misplaced $884 from her approximately $2,700 paycheck for two pay cycles, prompting her to choice up additional shifts at her hospital.

"It's the importance of the world," Bates said. "Some days are improved than others, but I didn't think I'd be here."

More student-loan borrowers could shortly discover themselves in Bates' situation. Private pupil loans comprised lone 10% of the $1.85 trillion student-loan market in 2025, according to Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Data. But President Donald Trump's repayment overhaul, which took consequence July 1, is expected to run additional borrowers to personal lenders akin Sallie Mae, which lack significant national oversight.

Business Insider's former reporting revealed general confusion in lender communication as borrowers moved toward default and litigation — concerning one in four complaints submitted alongside the CFPB in 2025 were concerning personal pupil loans.

A study from assistance collection Protect Borrowers stated that personal lenders sued additional than 100,000 borrowers between 2012 and 2016. Bates stated that her lawful procedure taught her that she's "very much not alone."

"At first, I was really embarrassed and ashamed to conversation concerning it," Bates said. "Now I'm entirely not."

What came following the lawsuit

Before defaulting, Bates was paying what she could oversee — about $560 a duration — but was unable to create her complete $1,500 payments. She tried and unsuccessful often to negotiate a lesser monthly bill, and didn't cognize how to return to fine standing following she defaulted.

"I didn't comprehend item for months," Bates said. "I had contacted them formerly or twice throughout this process, waiting to comprehend back, and no one always had an answer for me."

A Sallie Mae spokesman earlier told Business Insider that it could not comment on Bates' document and that the business "proactively and consistently" communicates alongside its customers, including sending notices whenever a client defaults, whenever that defaulted debt is sold, and notifying them of the new owner.

After Bates was sued, the fairness encouraged her alternatively to attain a colony or concur to a fee scheme alongside Sallie Mae. Bates stated Sallie Mae offered her a fee scheme of about $1,600 a duration — higher than the first payments that had led her to default in the archetypal place.

"That's not feasible," she stated following the hearing. "I am additional than consenting to pay rear what I took, but it needs to be a fee that is manageable, and that's not going to put me on the streets."

She requested a lesser fee scheme and waited months for Sallie Mae's sign-off. She saw in August that a garnishment notice had been added to her court docket. Weeks later, she misplaced a chunk of her paycheck.

"It's difficult going to activity knowing that alongside everything you agreement alongside and go through, you're not getting paid the way that you ultimately deserve," Bates said.

At the end of September, a fairness signed off on a scheme allowing her to create $600 monthly payments toward her balance until it is paid off. It won't be easy, she said, but it's preferable to losing concerning $1,700 a duration to pay garnishment.

"Home-wise, alongside bills and finances, it's not 100% feasible," Bates said. "But it's stated me several kind of empowerment since at smallest I have the domain rear in my court, and the prosperity won't fair be taken from me."

Bates volition commencement making payments through the court's fee scheme on November 1. Looking back, she wishes she had improved understood how lengthy litigation can be, so she could have improved prepared herself for the lawful battle ahead. While she motionless has years of payments to go, she's relieved to near this chapter.

"I'm optimistic," Bates said. "I awareness a lot improved mentally since it's not consuming my existence as much as it was."

Have a narrative to portion concerning pupil loans? Contact this newsman at [email protected].

Most popular