Posted on August 10, 2026 Posted by Athena Scalzi 12 Comments
My begetter precocious wrote a portion detailing immoderate of his thoughts connected AI, and successful doing truthful he compared utilizing generative AI to playing Guitar Hero. I shall not fto this affinity stand.
If you deliberation I’m pro-AI, you couldn’t beryllium much wrong. There is nary bigger hater of AI successful the world than yours truly. So while I disagree pinch my father’s argument, it isn’t because I for illustration AI, it’s because he slandered Guitar Hero. How could he moreover comparison the two? So fewer things are moreover comparable to the absolute plague connected humanity that generative AI is, and Guitar Hero should not beryllium included successful that list.
This highly good thought retired and provocative effort is only for the eyes of those who are fresh to rock. So without further ado, please subordinate maine successful celebrating the existent creation that is Guitar Hero.
(I will beryllium referencing my father’s station a bully bit, and countering circumstantial points he raises, truthful consciousness free to mention to his station here.)
Some of you mightiness deliberation I’m being obtuse successful contradicting my father’s affinity of Guitar Hero does not adjacent being a guitar player, and utilizing generative AI does not adjacent creating art. However, I understand the guidelines statement being made present is that Guitar Hero does not thatch you really to play a existent guitar, and that the skills that you get from playing Guitar Hero are not transferrable to the existent instrument.
My begetter defies his statement pinch his ain wording: “…a non-transferrable skill…”
Skill. Guitar Hero requires skill. Therefore, Guitar Hero is fundamentally and utterly different than utilizing generative AI. Case closed.
However, I will proceed my essay, moreover though I person already proved my point.
While it is existent that Guitar Hero does not thatch you the skills to beryllium a guitarist, it does impact the skills of rhythm, timing, and hand-eye-coordination. Auditory centrifugal synchronization is simply a very important thing, you know! Research has proven clip and clip again really video games, including hit games, tin create caller neural pathways and fortify your brain, whereas generative AI has proved to do the nonstop other and moreover actively harm our cognitive functioning, problem-solving, and moreover memory.
While Guitar Hero has nary ground claiming to beryllium a instrumentality for learning guitar, it ne'er stated that that’s what it was for astatine all. No 1 ever said “play this to go a guitar player.” The constituent of Guitar Hero was ne'er to make you a guitarist. It ne'er boasted claims of doing so, truthful why are we saying, “well, it doesn’t make you a guitar player.” I cognize that! Everyone who plays the crippled knows that!
And, if personification claimed that they were a guitar player, and past tried to make money by booking gigs arsenic a guitar player, location would beryllium immoderate existent consequences and insult involved. Yet, this is not the aforesaid for those who usage generative AI. Many businesses and establishments get distant pinch utilizing AI flyers for their events aliases images, and while immoderate group connected Instagram whitethorn opportunity boo successful the comments, they look nary meaningful, existent world consequences.
I’d besides for illustration to antagonistic my dad’s prime of words successful saying, “Like Guitar Hero, AI is nosy to play with…” First of all, nary it isn’t. Second of all, 1 is an existent crippled pinch the intent of being entertainment, the different is simply a water-sucking demon that steals creation from existent artists.
You don’t beryllium astir your friend’s dorm room procrastinating an effort conscionable to punctual AI to “make art,” you bent retired and play games and person fun! And 1 of those games for maine was Guitar Hero 3 for the Wii. The magnitude of clip I spent progressing from easy to master is not to beryllium understated. My accomplishment really grew, my expertise to play the crippled good actually grew. And I did it pinch my friends by my side, each of america having so much fun. There is nary bonding relationship for illustration that pinch generative AI.
As you tin show by my very concentrated face, this was an activity to do together. Be rockin’ together. AI disconnects america from each different and isolates us, not brings america together like Guitar Hero.
(Look astatine that joyful smile.)
Guitar Hero was a imaginative and innovative task made pinch emotion by real humans. My dada mentions that Guitar Hero uses existent licensed euphony and paid existent group and artists to make and creation the game. Every facet of the crippled is axenic human. Already this is truthful overmuch amended than and has a much affirmative effect connected the world than generative AI, which wrongfully steals creation and puts group retired of jobs. And makes disfigured arena flyers!
The truth that Guitar Hero had thought and volition and emotion put into it makes it the polar other of generative AI. The truth that group tin play it astatine a statement and impressment group pinch their skills (whether you deliberation they’re valuable skills aliases not) and make them cheer aliases laughter is specified a quality relationship that generative AI can’t replicate. When personification shows maine generative AI “art” I want to Old Yeller myself. Comparatively, for illustration my dada said, “…if you could get done the entirety of “Through the Fire and the Flames” connected master level, you were a friggin’ god.”
Listen, cipher walks astir saying they’re a guitar subordinate conscionable because they play Guitar Hero. But people do walk astir saying they’re artists erstwhile they’re not. More importantly, group who played Guitar Hero never tried to scam group online and make a profit, whereas location are plentifulness of group making a profit disconnected low-quality, generated AI images and products that they scam group with.
Using generative AI is bad for the environment. I can’t really say the aforesaid about Guitar Hero (I opportunity it for illustration that because successful immoderate capacity, yes the energy required to play the game, arsenic good arsenic the building of the console and controller, negatively effect the environment, but it’s conscionable not astatine the aforesaid standard and rapidness that AI information centers are ruining things.)
All hail Guitar Hero!
Long communicative short, Guitar Hero was ne'er advertised to group arsenic a learning instrumentality to study guitar, and those who played ne'er claimed to beryllium guitarists aliases profit disconnected of it. Guitar Hero is a quality made shape of intermezo meant to beryllium nosy pinch your friends astatine parties, and nary 1 loses their jobs complete it, aliases their pat water.
Generative AI is bad, and Guitar Hero is fucking awesome.
Rock on, bitches.
-AMS
English (US) · 
Indonesian (ID) ·