Why Building Trust Through Real People Stands The Test Of Time In SEO & AI Search

Search Engine Journal by 30 min read 30x views
Why Building Trust Through Real People Stands The Test Of Time In SEO & AI Search

Share Post

When it comes to integrated hunt marketing, a loophole is not a strategy. Loopholes have expiration dates, and in many cases, the period spent chasing them would have been improved spent on activity that doesn’t backfire afterward on.

Any SEO who has worked in the site for a during has inevitably lived through a apparently endless iteration of fads, hype cycles, and shortcuts aimed at tricking hunt engines (and now, AI systems). Exact-match domains, part directories, parasite SEO, visitant posting at scale, PBNs, programmatic pages, and now the AI-generated listicles, scaled AI content, and “inauthentic mentions” of the GEO era. Most of these things activity for a while… until they don’t. And formerly Google, Bing, and additional lately the AI companies themselves expert down, the sites that leaned on these approaches frequently end up worse off than if they’d never tried them at all, sometimes spending years cleaning up during traffic, visibility, and leads remain suppressed.

Plenty of group in this industry have battle scars from these experiences, myself included. My archetypal genuine SEO wins came from purchasing links in 2010-2011, and Penguin erased them in a sole morning in 2012. Six years later, the 2018 “Medic” update hit a client of ours that had been using AI and automation to measure medicinal satisfied (long before this was popular), and it was the hardest hit from an algorithm update that I had informed firsthand since the Penguin update. I think these scars are the sign of regard that inevitably comes alongside cognition in SEO: thinking you cognize improved than Google, and learning the difficult way that you nearly continually don’t.

All of that said, there is one funding that has held up through all one of those cycles, and it’s the identical method I’ve recommended for many years: investing in genuine humans and placing them at the center of your promotion strategy. As AI makes generic satisfied nearly liberated to produce, I accept that real, identifiable experts are becoming the clearest antidote to scaled, machine-generated slop. This part covers why, what the evidence shows so far, and how brands can regard “human-centric marketing” as a bigger part of their strategies.

Google Has Been Saying The Same Thing For 20+ Years

What I discover interesting, looking back, is how accordant Google’s direction has been the complete time, if you peruse between the lines (or peruse the guidelines at all). Google’s Webmaster Guidelines from 2003 (yes, 23 years ago) already told location owners to “make pages for users, not for hunt engines,” and warned against “cookie cutter” approaches alongside “little or no first content.” They equal stated that location owners following the soul of the guidelines would do improved than “those who expend their period looking for loopholes they can exploit.”

 evade hidden content or links, cloaking, automated queries, irrelevant words, copy pages, and entrance or “cookie cutter” pages alongside small or no first content.
Google’s Webmaster Guidelines as of December 2003, via the Wayback Machine. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)

The catalog of spam violations Google laid out rear afterward has carried on, in several form, for additional than 20 years, correct into the AI hunt era. I put together this infographic showing how Google’s first spam policies map to famous GEO strategies we see today alongside AI search:

 What’s Old is New Again,” matching Google’s 2003 norm guidelines to 2026 AI hunt tactics, specified as hidden content and hidden prompts for LLMs, cloaking and distinct pages for bots, and entrance pages and programmatic pages at scale.
Google’s 2003 norm guidelines, flank by flank alongside famous AI hunt strategies in 2026. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)

Automation in particular has been in the crosshairs for fine complete a decade. In August 2010, Google’s John Mueller told a location owner that publishing Google Translate output immediately “could be seen as creating auto-generated content, which would be against our Webmaster Guidelines,” and recommended having a individual accurate it first. By 2012, Google had published a dedicated assistance leaf on automatically generated content. Its examples included content “translated by an automated tool without individual assessment or curation,” Markov chains, automated synonymizing, scraped feeds, and “stitching or combining satisfied from distinct web pages without adding adequate value.”

Screenshot of Google’s 2012 assistance leaf on automatically generated content, listing examples specified as content translated by an automated tool without individual review, Markov chains, automated synonymizing, scraped feeds, and stitched-together content.
Google’s assistance leaf on automatically generated content, October 2012, via the Wayback Machine. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)

For what it’s worth, I motionless see this exact matter affecting sites today – perchance additional than always – including companies who arrive to me following experimenting alongside scaled AI translations that get small individual review. It’s engaging that John’s 15+ twelvemonth old answer motionless holds up, although to be fair, most location owners have never peruse Google’s guidelines (and nobody can be expected to cognize concerning a forum answer from 2010). That’s what their SEO experts are (supposedly) there to assistance them with.

Funny enough, that 2012 catalog says a lot akin the revenue throw for the identical AI satisfied tools that have lately captured the notice of C-level marketers everywhere, many of which activity in ways that arrive extremely near to (if not immediately violate) Google’s long-standing anti-spam policies. It’s not a huge astonishment that so many of the sites featured in their case studies have since quickly misplaced integrated traffic.

Google’s wording has evolved since then, but the thread operating through it has stayed remarkably consistent. In February 2023, a few months following ChatGPT launched, Google stated it has “many years of cognition dealing alongside automation being used in an attempt to equivalent hunt results.” Then in March 2024, Google launched the scaled satisfied abuse spam policy, which applies whether satisfied is made “through automation, individual efforts, or several blend of individual and automated processes.” Automated translation, synonymizing, and stitching are motionless on the list, 14 years later. Marketers are now using LLMs to test heavily alongside all three. The chief difference now is that generative AI sits at the top of the catalog of examples.

Across additional than 20 years of guidelines, the average thread is fairly simple: satisfied made for hunt engines at scale, alongside no individual reviewing it, adding to it, or position rearward it, eventually becomes a liability.

E-E-A-T Gave Us A Way Out Of The Loop

When Google started using the acronym “E-A-T” in 2014 (now called “E-E-A-T”), it eventually gave us a example that shows how to equal do SEO activity without getting caught up in the loopholes. Since then, E-E-A-T has been misunderstood, misused, and treated as a checklist or a sole ranking aspect that plant the identical way for all location (it doesn’t). In 2021, I equal wrote an part aimed specifically at debunking many of these misconceptions.

All of that being said, I motionless to this day accept E-E-A-T is the finest example we have for approaching our SEO/GEO strategies in ways that won’t be penalized or devalued later, and it gives us plentifulness of meaningful activity to do formerly we concentration on the correct things. There’s a logic E-E-A-T is mentioned 120 times in the current type of Google’s Search Quality Rater Guidelines, and why Bing uses akin language, focusing on “quality and credibility,” in its own guidelines.

This category of activity is people-first, definition genuine humans alongside lived cognition sit at the center of the approach. It’s much harder than loophole-focused SEO, since it needs buy-in, time, and resources from the experts at the company, not fair the SEO squad functioning rearward the scenes. But the come back is high, and it affects additional channels than fair organic. It tends to remain the test of time; it’s fine for your users and your conversions; it appears to assistance alongside AI systems; and it’s improbable to get you penalized (unless you use a shortcut mindset to it, which isn’t really an E-E-A-T scheme at all). It’s additionally the contrary of what folks publically say they dislike concerning the effect SEO has had on Google’s results, from The Verge asking whether SEO experts ruined the internet to a 2024 study finding merchandise assessment results increasingly complete of SEO spam.

Why I’ve Made Humans The Focal Point Of My SEO/GEO Approach

I’ve been preaching these identical ideas for years, and I likely audio akin a damaged document to anyone who has followed me for a during (my MozCon 2022 conversation was all concerning how to concentration on genuine expertise, alongside many examples of genuine experts representing the brands they worked for). I equal named my holistic method to SEO/GEO the E-E-A-T Method and made it the center doctrine of my new consultancy, Algorythmic, since that’s how deeply I accept in the efficacy of this approach.

But this wasn’t continually a big concentration in how I approached SEO; it’s something I learned the difficult way.

That 2018 Medic client I referred to before had been scaling a fast-growing archive of health articles alongside no apparent credentials from experts, and no sign of a genuine individual rearward any of it. When the update hit, Google’s Danny Sullivan pointed location owners rear to the Search Quality Rater Guidelines (his tweet has since been deleted, but Marie Haynes wrote concerning his guidance at the time). So I spent months study and re-reading Google’s guidelines. Being the nerd that I am, I equal printed and laminated a copy and kept it on my array (which I admitted on stage in 2019 at BrightonSEO). When I peruse it, the answer to our client’s difficulty became obvious, and it was repeated throughout the guidelines: the location was heavily YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) and showed nowhere near adequate E-A-T for the health topics it covered and the medicinal direction it provided.

The client wasn’t convinced at first, as this required a theatrical overhaul of their method – so much so that we decided to part ways during they tried to bring rear the site’s achievement using their own methods. But following nearly two years without recovering, the client came rear to activity alongside our squad again. We worked together on a renewed SEO strategy, and concerning six months later, we relaunched the complete site, rebuilt from top to base about E-A-T, alongside individual experts at the center: genuine doctors, genuine medicinal reviewers, and their first insights. The location climbed rear to its former levels following the re-platforming was complete. From the day the update hit, the complete improvement procedure took additional than three years. (This long improvement timeline is why I continually notify sites to evade getting hit in the archetypal place!)

Slide from a MozCon display showing a traffic diagram tagged “‘Recovery’ took 3+ years… and required a brand new website,” next to the speaker on stage.
A screenshot from my 2023 MozCon presentation concerning center updates, showing the improvement journey of our client affected by the Medic update. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)

Back in January 2019, the night before my first-ever gathering conversation at SMX West (which was – surprise! – focused on E-A-T), I sat at the inn bar studying Mark Traphagen’s work on author authority. He, alongside alongside Jennifer Slegg, had been documenting the former of “authorship” and “author authority” on Google complete time. (Funny flank note: I ended up gathering Mark in individual for the archetypal period at the gathering dawn meal the next morning, a few hours before I went on stage, which felt auspicious.) After my presentation, whenever an attendee asked what a small location should do if its writers aren’t fine known, my answer was to “cultivate your authors’ profiles, equal if it method starting from scratch,” which ruffled several feathers in a area filled alongside specialized SEOs who didn’t all buy into the idea that Google could fig these things out. Yet nearly eight years of investigation and client results later, I’m equal additional convinced that it can.

A few months later, Google’s official direction on center updates connected to my BrightonSEO phase on E-A-T as a recommended resource, alongside alongside activity from a few another SEOs. This solidified for me that E-A-T was becoming a big precedence for them. In 2020, I had the awesome privilege of digging into the patents that power explain how E-A-T works alongside the late, awesome Bill Slawski, whose cognition of Google’s patents was unmatched. This exercise helped me comprehend a additional specialized clarification for how Google’s systems power acknowledge idiosyncratic experts. The following year, I took the topic to the MozCon phase alongside a conversation on how the E-A-T ecosystem has transformed integrated search.

Search Engine Journal part depiction study “E-A-T & Search Patents” alongside a Google logo on a colorful painted background.
“The Mechanics of E-A-T: How Google Patents Can Help Explain How E-A-T Works,” Search Engine Journal, October 2020. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)

What I Mean By “Real Humans”

“Humanize your brand” and “keep a individual in the loop” have rotate into promotion clichés of their own, so I desire to be specific. By “real humans,” I average practitioners alongside genuine ability or experience: the doctor who has treated the condition, the engineer who built the system, the plumber who owns a local plumbing business, or the tolerant who lived through the illness. They acquire their spectators naturally, and throughout platforms, by sharing insights that are honest, original, frequently opinionated, and according to genuine experience. You can normally inform them distinct from person who showed up to market you something, and if a transaction happens at all, it tends to prosecute from the rely they’ve built.

My approach, for SEO, AI search, and broader marketing, is to put these genuine group at the center of the scheme whenever possible. It’s additionally what I’ve employed alongside my own individual brand (more on that later).

I think this is the scheme most apt to last any comes next, for a uncomplicated reason. Nearly all famous shortcut in the vicious sequence of SEO could be scaled. A genuine expert’s position can’t. It takes years of showing up, being correct (and sometimes wrong, and open to admitting that) in public, and having another group vouch for you without needing to depend on inauthentic mentions or listicles calling yourself the finest expert. As AI makes everything alternatively cheaper to produce, I’d anticipate the value of that benevolent of earned position to keep climbing.

In April 2024, on the Authority Hacker podcast, I summed it up alongside among the sentences I’ve stated most frequently in my career:

“I’ve been talking concerning this for years: People akin following people.”

(Jump to 53:26):

Sidenote: Don’t intellect the shade beginning the entrance rearward me. That was my dog Marcy, who can never decide anywhere she wants to lie downward whenever I’m doing podcasts.

What Real People Bring That AI Can’t

It’s no concealed that folks on social platforms affect alongside another group far additional than alongside brands. On LinkedIn, personal profiles outperform business pages by approximately 2x to 8x on impressions, depending on whose data you believe.

Here’s what genuine group bring to the array that AI can’t:

  • Expertise earned complete years in the trenches. Someone who has spent 10 or 20 years doing the activity has seen what happens after the direction gets followed: the border cases, the things that broke, or why certain products are improved than others. That form acknowledgment lone comes from lived experience, and it’s frequently exactly the flat of helpful understanding that folks are looking for whenever they go searching for advice. An LLM can summarize what others have written concerning a job, but it has never had to do the job itself.
  • Feelings and lived experience. AI doesn’t have feelings (even although it “feels” to us akin it sometimes might). It has never sat alongside a frightened patient, misplaced a big client, or been nervous before a archetypal gathering talk. It can imitate empathy and humor, but it can’t diagram on experiences it never had, which is a big part of why AI penning so frequently feels old (and sometimes a small alien). Writing from person who has really been through the item says differently, and it matters to readers that a genuine individual is rearward it: throughout nine experiments alongside additional than 6,000 people, the identical supportive communication was rated as more empathic and additional genuine whenever folks believed a individual wrote it.
  • Something new to the conversation. AI tools are getting improved at investigation and analysis, and plentifulness of folks (myself included) use them to assistance activity through data. But person motionless has to decide which inquiry is value asking, bring data or cognition nobody alternatively has, and put their name rearward the conclusion. Google’s helpful satisfied guidance asks whether satisfied provides “original information, reporting, research, or analysis,” and in my experience, that motionless starts alongside a individual (even if that individual is using AI in the process).
    • Left on its own, AI tends to drag everyone toward the identical answer: a 2026 study in PNAS Nexus established that foremost AI models mark concerning as fine as group on ingenuity tests, but their answers are far additional akin to all another than people’s are.
  • Humor and personality. Inside jokes, a client call that became awkward, a baby or dog wandering into a podcast record (looking at you, Marcy). That material seems to be a big part of why folks awareness akin they cognize the group they follow. There’s a term for that feeling: Cambridge Dictionary named “parasocial” its 2025 Word of the Year, describing a association person feels alongside a celebrated individual or online character that they don’t really know.
  • Flaws and vulnerability. Psychologists call part of this the pratfall effect: in a 1966 experiment, a extremely capable individual became more likable following spilling a cup of coffee. In my experience, my posts anywhere I acknowledge I don’t cognize something, or portion what I learned from my own mistakes, lean to get powerful involvement from others who have felt the identical way. People appear to affect alongside that far additional than alongside confident-sounding AI-splaining.

Real Humans Leave A Trail

Across platforms, signs of a genuine individual may be the clearest way to distinct spam and automated satisfied from the satisfied that provides the most value.

A genuine individual expert leaves evidence everywhere, and that footprint is effortlessly detectable: photos from the gathering they said at, video of the talk, a individual website (even a slightly neglected one), podcast interviews, years of social posts and replies, or journalists quoting them by name. I accept Google has systems in location to at smallest acknowledge these signals, and apt reward them, from Knowledge Panels to the new Search profiles. The leaked Google documentation from May 2024 points in the identical direction: it showed that Google stores the author of a document, and has an trait called isAuthor that marks whether an being mentioned on a leaf is additionally the author of that page.

The representative counterfeit author, on the another hand, has a stock-looking AI-generated headshot, a two-sentence bio (if any), and no another evidence of their genuine beingness anyplace on the web. This method isn’t constricted to small sites, either: in 2023, Sports Illustrated was found publishing merchandise reviews under authors who didn’t appear to exist, including one whose headshot was for transaction on a location that sells AI-generated portraits. In that identical year, counterfeit authors were one of the most average patterns I established among sites hit by the Helpful Content Update, and in October 2026, Google added this exact tactic to its helpful satisfied documentation: “Fabricating creator profiles (such as by using AI-generated headshots, made-up names, or false credentials to create satisfied appear as if it was written by individual experts) is a form of deception.”

I foretell that this trail of being a “real human” volition matter equal additional as the web fills up alongside homogeneous vibe-coded sites. Anyone can now rotation up a polished website in an afternoon, complete alongside a logo, a hundred blog posts, and a squad leaf complete of affable AI-generated headshots. If you’ve looked at many of these sites, you’ve likely noticed they all commencement to appearance the same: the same purple gradient, the identical three characteristic cards alongside emoji icons, the identical “Trusted by” logo strip.

Mock homepage for a fictional AI startup alongside a purple gradient, the header “Revolutionize Your Workflow alongside AI-Powered Synergy,” three characteristic cards alongside emoji icons, a “Trusted by” logo strip, and a “Meet the Experts” row of AI-generated headshots.
A (fictional) vibe-coded homepage, assembled from the parts all vibe-coded homepage seems to share. Thanks, Claude. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)

When a convincing-looking brand expenses next to nothing and takes small period to build, polish solitary doesn’t inform anyone extremely much anymore. What’s remaining are the signals that motionless obtain years to build: a genuine individual or genuine group alongside genuine histories, who another genuine group have chosen to follow, quote, and recommend.

Search Is Rebuilding Itself Around Real Voices

Since the 2018 Medic update, Google appears to have spent the former 8 years construction systems that reward exactly that benevolent of trail. In 2019, I analyzed 64 sites that had plainly won or misplaced throughout the 2018 and 2019 center updates, checking all one for 30 on-page E-A-T signals and researching the credentials of the group penning their content. The winning sites were 258% additional apt than the losing sites to use genuine experts on their satisfied (with the customary caveat that this was a small sample, and association isn’t causation). Since then, Google has put many of those identical observations into writing:

  • December 2022: the E for Experience, making E-A-T into E-E-A-T. When Google added “Experience” to E-A-T, I wrote up the changes for Search Engine Land, including a new division on the position of idiosyncratic creators and a row asking raters to measure the “extent to which a individual being actively worked to create satisfying content.”
    • Google had already been moving in this direction. Starting in 2021, its Product Reviews updates rewarded reviews that showed evidence the reviewer had really used the product, akin first photos, videos, or measurements from evaluation it. That’s item a genuine individual can do comparatively easily, and scaled, machine-generated satisfied mostly can’t. Garage Gym Reviews is a fine example: its equipment is tested by certified individual trainers, coaches, and rivalrous athletes who really lift, run, and row on it. Travel + Leisure does item similar, sending products to its evaluation lab in New York and out on genuine trips alongside its journey editors. In the two cases, genuine group alongside lived cognition are doing the evaluation and the writing. I think these updates were an first sign of how much importance Google planned to put on genuine individual experience.
  • 2023: Reddit takes complete in the “Hidden Gems” era of Search. In May 2023, Google stated it wanted to exterior additional “hidden gems,” akin a forum comment or a article on a small blog. Later that year, it confirmed the changes had been rolling out for months as part of center ranking, built to display additional firsthand cognition and individual cognition from forums, social media, and blogs.
    • By November 2023, I was posting on LinkedIn that Google seemed to be “way overindexing on ‘authentic content’ and ‘real experience'” in its hunt results. Social media, UGC, and forums were by far the biggest winning category in my 2023 winners and losers analysis, and my erstwhile intern Silvia Gituto’s deep dive on Reddit established it went from the 68th to the 5th most apparent domain in Google’s US hunt results (per Sistrix) in a sole year. At one point, a five-year-old Reddit article from a since-deleted document outranked the Mayo Clinic for “how to potty train a boy.” The era of genuine experience-focused UGC had arrived.
Sistrix Visibility Index diagram for reddit.com showing flat visibility from 2017 until mid-2023, followed by a steep ascend that peaks complete 3,000 points.
Reddit’s enormous visibility growth on Google between 2023 and 2024, according to the Sistrix Visibility Index. (Image Credit: Lily Ray)
  • 2025 and 2026: a renewed concentration on idiosyncratic creators. In September 2025, Google redesigned Google Discover so users can follow idiosyncratic creators, afterward launched Search profiles: claimable, verified pages for creators that users can prosecute immediately from Search.
    • In October 2026, Damien Andell of 1492.vision flagged a Google job posting concerning turning Discover into a “proactive, hyper-personalized feed,” and noted that it explicitly calls for keeping individual voices and sources at the center. His squad has additionally documented Instagram and TikTok posts being tested in Discover, alongside X and YouTube. With these changes, idiosyncratic creators get to perform a bigger part in Google’s type of a personalized social feed.

AI Search Cites The Places Where People Share What They Know

Real experts and genuine lived experiences appear to run a big portion of AI hunt citations, and you can see it in which sites get cited most. YouTube and Reddit are consistently the two most cited websites in Google’s AI Overviews, at 24.5% and 18.1% of citations among the top 50 cited domains in Ahrefs’ November 2026 analysis.

Other studies item to LinkedIn, too. In a Semrush study of 325,000 prompts before this year, LinkedIn was the second most cited domain in ChatGPT Search, Google AI Mode, and Perplexity, and 59% of the LinkedIn satisfied cited in ChatGPT Search and AI Mode came from idiosyncratic members fairly than business pages.

This doesn’t astonishment me – I’ve seen my LinkedIn posts and Pulse articles display up in Google’s AI hunt results immediately following publishing, akin this test I did alongside a LinkedIn Pulse part concerning Google Discover. It earned the top ranking in AI Overviews and an AI Mode citation inside seven hours of publishing.

Screenshot from X, November 2026
Screenshot from X, November 2026

In another words, a lot of the data AI hunt systems diagram on to build responses comes from the places anywhere genuine humans go to portion what they really know, akin a creator on YouTube strolling through how they fixed item or which merchandise they akin best, a Reddit thread complete of firsthand experience, or a practitioner’s thoughtful LinkedIn article or Pulse article. Unfortunately, these identical platforms are additionally being inundated alongside AI slop, and it’s not a secret.

YouTube And Reddit Are Cracking Down On Inauthentic Content

YouTube and Reddit have been fairly definitive concerning what they want, and it additionally points to authentic individual experiences. In July 2025, YouTube renamed its “repetitious content” monetization rule to “inauthentic content,” covering AI-generated videos made from generic templates “without adding the creator’s original, authentic insights or perspective,” and CEO Neal Mohan’s 2026 letter called out “AI slop” by name. Reddit CEO Steve Huffman wrote in February that “if you can’t effortlessly differentiate a genuine person’s thoughts or recommendations from a bot, that rely erodes,” and a duration afterward Reddit started labeling automated accounts. On the two platforms, the most dependable way to visibility appears to be the one this entire article is about: be a real, identifiable individual – sharing authentic and honest experiences – whom another group choose to trust.

One Person Can Change How A Company Is Perceived

I’ve seen firsthand what sharing publically can do for a business. When I joined Amsive, I had never stated an SEO conversation on a phase or done item public-facing in the industry. Since then, in nearly nine years on the agency’s SEO team, I’ve published investigation on its blog under my own name, alongside podcast interviews, gathering talks, webinars, and another promotion efforts on the agency’s behalf. That activity has brought the agency links, traffic, and name acknowledgment that keep expanding lengthy following all part goes live. When I lately looked at the agency’s backlinks in Ahrefs, a few things stood out:

  • Interviews and collaborations I’ve done alongside journalists have earned Amsive links and brand mentions on high-authority publications akin the New York Times, BBC, Washington Post, CNET, and many more.
  • Nine of the 10 most-linked articles on amsive.com are first data studies from the SEO team, including seven I wrote or contributed to.
  • About 1 in 13 of the approximately 7,800 sites linking to amsive.com citation my name in or correct next to the link, normally as a citation from an part or interview.
  • My author leaf on amsive.com is connected from 120 sites, additional than all but seven of the company’s articles.

I’m sharing this since of anywhere those links point: all one of them goes to the company. One individual (or a squad of people) sharing what they cognize under their own names can develop a company’s authority in a way that brand satisfied on its own rarely does. I’ve seen the identical form at countless another brands that put trusted experts at the forefront of their marketing, and I try to employ this identical method in my client strategies.

Of course, I’m not the lone example of this, and others in the industry are seeing achievement alongside the identical approach. For years, Wix had what the Ahrefs blog called “a bit of a bad position for SEO.” Plenty of SEOs would have steered clients distant from it. Then Wix did item smart: it hired respected SEOs akin Crystal Carter and Mordy Oberstein to portray the brand inside the SEO community.

Crystal joined in 2022, and since afterward she has spoken at many important hunt and promotion conferences, co-hosted Wix’s SERP’s Up podcast, and published her own investigation on the Wix site. Today, whenever SEO publications compose concerning whether Wix is fine for SEO, they frequently item to her by name. That identical Ahrefs part credits her and Mordy alongside pushing for “more SEO features and improved communication.” About 1 in 20 sites linking to Wix’s SEO Hub citation Crystal by name, the podcast shows up in “best SEO podcasts” roundups from Backlinko and Ahrefs, and her expert leaf is the most-linked expert overview on the hub.

For a additional celebrated example exterior our industry, appearance at journey expert Rick Steves. He self-published his archetypal journey guide in 1980, and he has spent concerning four months a twelvemonth in Europe for decades, strolling the routes himself and updating his guidebooks all year. That one person’s lived cognition grew into a business alongside additional than 100 employees, a PBS sequence that has run since 2000, a thriving forum and online community, a community broadcast show, and a tour program that takes additional than 30,000 travelers to Europe all year.

I wrote concerning his location on LinkedIn this summer, calling it the ultimate embodiment of E-E-A-T and the ideal example of an expert-led promotion approach. He tells you – from firsthand cognition – what’s overrated, overpriced, or skippable, and since he makes prosperity from books and tours, his satisfied is liberated from affiliate influence. His honesty is the product. Google’s AI Overviews frequently citation his website, and his YouTube and TikTok pages too.

How To Build A Human-First Strategy With Brand Evangelists

Brands that can should commencement by identifying the genuine experts inner the business and investing in making them visible. In practice:

  • Find the boots on the dirt – the group who really cognize things. Your merchandise lead, your caput of support, the engineer who answers all difficult inquiry in Slack, or the originator who motionless takes client calls.
  • Build up their existence on your site. Focus on construction sturdy About pages, author and expert pages, and any another chance to showcase the genuine group and genuine experts at the company. Use their author profiles to emphasize the awesome activity they’ve done, nexus to their social properties, and treat the leaf as a individual portfolio for the expert. Give them a voice, and a way of contributing to business communications, whether it’s contributing to the blog or construction a phase on LinkedIn to assistance their efforts at the company.
  • Encourage them to build an expert footprint exterior your site. Experts can provision gathering talks, do podcast interviews, or assistance alongside posts on Reddit (or equal assistance oversee the authoritative tagged subreddit), LinkedIn, or another online communities anywhere your buyers expend time. Help them acquire and assertion their Knowledge Panel and, whenever they qualify, their Search profile. Think of it as a way for them to build their individual brand, during simultaneously expanding visibility for the company.
  • Keep the throw out of it. Folks prosecute group who are genuinely helpful to them, and productive promotion is increasingly becoming authentic, not salesy. Share the data, the mistakes, the “I don’t cognize yet,” and credit another people’s activity generously.
  • Make your group uncomplicated to verify. In October, I shared that the most cited leaf on an endeavor client’s location in AI Overviews and AI Mode was its About page: a detailed, human-readable former of the company. I motionless accept About pages are typically underinvested in.
Screenshot from X, November 2026

Two fair counterpoints, since this method isn’t imaginable for all company: Some industries have compliance teams that create individual posting genuinely hard. And group may depart the business and obtain their individual brands alongside them. My answer is to try to build multiple voices alternatively of relying on one (my companion and coworker Viola Eva recently wrote concerning how they do exactly this at her company, Flow Agency). Furthermore, recall that any links, mentions, and safety earned during person represented the business can remain as precious resources for the company, equal following they move on.

Why This Stands The Test Of Time

In July 2023, I posted on LinkedIn that equal if Google couldn’t inform AI satisfied from individual content, person alternatively could: “guess who alternatively doesn’t akin study AI content? USERS.” The person investigation has since caught up. A Gartner survey this summer established that a majority of U.S. consumers say AI satisfied has made them small trusting of brand messaging, and Emplifi’s 2026 research established that only 35% of Americans rely AI-generated satisfied at all (not that everyone can necessarily inform the difference). I’d call it slop fatigue, and I think the platforms are eventually responding to it (or at smallest trying to).

Every maneuver that has blown up in this industry, from the links I bought in 2011 to the listicles and paid mentions all complete the net in 2026, was scaled for the sole intent of driving visibility in search. That’s also, nearly exactly, the catalog of things consumers say they dislike most concerning SEO. Real experts and informed contributors have the contrary effect: they contribute the things that create the net human, and the most popular, extensively cited platforms are operating difficult to maintain their humanness in an net inundated alongside AI slop.

There’s another logic this holds up: your position is ultimately decided by what another group say concerning you, not by what you say concerning yourself. One of the rater regulation passages I put on a glide back in 2019 reads: “When there is disagreement between what the website says concerning itself and what reputable autonomous sources say concerning the website, we’ll rely the autonomous sources.”

AI hunt is carrying that torch forward, as LLMs are getting improved and improved at determining someone’s position according to what others say concerning the brand or the person. That appears to increasingly contain spotting self-promotion. Gemini now shows its reasoning steps, and in this example (h/t Gagan Ghotra), it immediately evaluated whether “Best AI SEO agency” lists were self-promotional, alongside agencies ranking themselves highly, to fairness how goal those rankings were. Being genuinely recommended by another group is the most sustainable way forward.

Screenshot from X, November 2026

People akin following people. That was true before Google, and it’ll motionless be true following any comes next. The brands that fig that out won’t need the next loophole.

More Resources:


This article was initially published on Lily Ray NYC Substack.


Featured Image: Spiximcreation/Shutterstock

Category SEO AI Search
Other Article Search Engine Journal
↑
Close Right Ads
Close Left Ads