Why AI Recommends Your Competitor & What To Do About It

Aug 04, 2026 12:30 AM - 3 hours ago 4

Kris Jones joined maine for an section of MCP’s podcast. He has been successful hunt since the precocious 1990s and now runs the agency LSEO, aft building and trading Pepper Jam. We spent astir of the speech connected 1 question, which is what really decides whether an AI strategy recommends your brand.

Kris gave maine a one-word reply early on, and everything other successful the section came backmost to it. The connection was synthesis. Listen to the complete section here.

[06:02] — AI Took Over The Comparison Step

[07:33] — Why Brand Is The Bridge

[13:33] — The Awards Your Competitors Are Applying For

[18:32] — Brand Messaging Is The New NAP Consistency

[21:23] — When AI Overviews Get Your Pricing Wrong

[28:56] — How People Are Actually Asking

[37:29] — Beyond ChatGPT And Google

AI Took Over The Comparison Step

Traditional hunt handed you options and near the comparing to you. You opened tabs, weighed what you found, and decided. Kris pointed retired that AI systems now do that comparing connected the user’s behalf and manus backmost a decision.

Traditional hunt fundamentally worked to supply you pinch options to reply your question. You’re required to do the synthesis. Whereas pinch AI, AI changed the crippled by doing the synthesis. [06:33]

That puts the personification overmuch person to the extremity of their investigation than a page of bluish links ever did. If the exemplary includes you, the purchaser shows up already advised. If it leaves you out, they ne'er brushwood you astatine all.

I described it connected the section arsenic a concierge alternatively than a paper catalog. A room utilized to springiness you the 20 champion resources successful classed bid and nonstop you disconnected to do the reading. Now thing sounds the apical 100 sources for you and comes backmost pinch a recommendation.

Kris was honorable that this involves a leap of faith. People are accepting synthesized answers and acting connected them without opening the sources underneath.

Why Brand Is The Bridge

I asked Kris wherever these systems are pulling their accusation from. His reply was marque signals, and specifically what different group are publishing astir you.

That reframes the work. You are nary longer trying to triumph a position connected a results page. You are trying to beryllium the answer, and the earthy worldly for that reply sits connected websites you do not own.

Kris besides put a number connected really overmuch of your existent programme still matters. In his estimate, 70% to 80% of AI hunt optimization is basal SEO practice, pinch the remainder covering the newer third-party work. His proposal to marketers was direct: Do not occurrence your SEO company.

That tracks pinch really the manufacture sewage here. Google spent years training everyone connected what it rewards, from featured snippets to system markup. As I put it connected the episode, the displacement complete the past 5 years from penning for group to penning for what Google rewards is simply a ample portion of what trained these models.

So dainty this arsenic a furniture connected apical of what you already fund. The fund displacement is smaller than the vendor sound suggests, and astir of it belongs successful earned media.

The Awards Your Competitors Are Applying For

Kris named the cheapest contiguous measurement disposable to astir businesses, and it is 1 plentifulness of marketers person softly written off. Identify each reliable third-party grant and nickname disposable successful your industry, past spell get them.

He knows the objection. Many of these programs are salary to play, and the aforesaid names look to triumph each year. His consequence stuck pinch me:

Those are the companies that are showing up successful the AI recommendations. [34:54]

The aforesaid logic covers comparison and best-of sum connected publications pinch existent authority. Kris based on that erstwhile an established patient successful a class writes up the apical platforms successful that space, the portion becomes 1 of the strongest sources a exemplary tin tie connected later.

One point worthy saying plainly. Publishing your ain “best agencies successful our category” station pinch your sanction astatine the apical is spam, and Kris called it that himself. The worth present depends connected the root being independent of you.

Brand Messaging Is The New NAP Consistency

Getting mentioned is not the decorativeness line. Kris kept coming backmost to the discourse of a mention, meaning what the surrounding contented really says astir you.

He compared it to the early days of section SEO, erstwhile we each learned that a business name, address, and telephone number had to lucifer everyplace they appeared. The aforesaid subject now applies to your marque messaging. What does the web opportunity your merchandise does, what does it opportunity you charge, and does immoderate of that still lucifer reality?

What has changed is that AI hunt output now feeds a strategy answering customer questions directly, which raises the costs of leaving old accusation retired there.

When AI Overviews Gets Your Pricing Wrong

I person a actual illustration of what that costs.

I worked pinch a concatenation of big acquisition schools whose tuition figures were being pulled into Google AI Overviews from a Reddit thread that was astir a decade old. The number showing up was astir 30% beneath what the schools really charged.

The mislaid conversions were the evident problem. The bigger messiness was everything downstream. Prospective students called successful confused, and immoderate were annoyed, wanting to cognize why the value had gone up. Nobody had raised the price. A forum station from 10 years agone was mounting mendacious expectations.

It takes publishing meticulous existent accusation successful capable reliable places that the AI models person aggregate corroborating sources to activity from alternatively of 1 old thread.

Don’t Set Your Baseline From ChatGPT And Google

One extremity I want group to return retired of this speech is to widen the list. When you get into your Google Analytics data, the click complaint coming from ChatGPT will astir apt baseline little than you expect. It grows from here, and truthful does the postulation from each different motor group are using.

The surfaces support multiplying. Kris mentioned utilizing Grok successful his Tesla, which makes evident consciousness erstwhile you link in-vehicle AI to navigation and section search. Meta AI is sitting correct wrong Instagram and Facebook successful beforehand of an tremendous audience, and it is not an motor our manufacture talks astir much.

Behavior is what is driving that. I seldom spot the group astir maine typing into these apps. They clasp a speech pinch ChatGPT and return the answer, and arsenic Kris pointed out, children particularly usage sound search. Kris uses sound AI regularly himself, and his publication is that a spoken mobility carries the aforesaid intent arsenic a typed one. The sources shaping those answers matter conscionable arsenic overmuch either way.

If you size your AI visibility fund against the referral postulation those engines nonstop you today, you are moving from a number that is mini now and rising. Kris made the constituent that the benefits of this benignant of activity play retired complete time, but it’s champion to get started while AI hunt is still young. The benefits tin beryllium a unit multiplier down the road.

What Should Marketers Tackle First?

Two things from this section are worthy acting connected earlier your adjacent readying cycle.

The first is an audit. Ask an AI adjunct to urge a vendor successful your category, publication what it says astir you, and cheque whether immoderate of it is retired of date.

The 2nd is the awards database you person been ignoring. Kris’s statement is that the companies collecting those recognitions are the ones the models cite. You tin determine to spell aft them this quarter, and it does not require building thing new.

Traditional hunt is still present and still worthy funding. What changed is that the comparison measurement moved, and the inputs to that comparison are sitting connected different people’s websites.

Connect pinch Kristopher Jones:

  • LinkedIn
  • X

Connect pinch Loren Baker:

  • LinkedIn
  • X

More Resources:

  • AI Overviews Now Answer Most Local Searches – How To Get Your Business Cited
  • Why Digital PR Fundamentals Beat AI Tactics: What Marketing Leaders Should Focus On
  • Research Suggests AI Engines Assign Ranking Roles To Sources

Featured Image: Paulo Bobita/MCP

Category SEJ Podcast SEO Generative AI
Follow Us On Google
More