What smart people are saying about Trump's ban on new Chinese humanoid robots

Responding to FCC Chair Brendan Carr's X station astir the ban, Chris McGuire said this was a "very, very large deal."

McGuire is simply a elder chap for China and emerging exertion astatine the Council connected Foreign Relations.

He said successful his Tuesday X station that the prohibition will incentivize the US to statement up its robotics proviso chains while "preventing China from flooding the US marketplace pinch inexpensive robots that besides airs nationalist information risks (similar to Chinese connected vehicles)."

McGuire praised the maneuver of imposing import bans connected circumstantial quickly increasing technologies from China that could airs nationalist information risks to the US.

Rush Doshi, the head of the China Strategy Initiative astatine the Council connected Foreign Relations, called the prohibition "one of the astir important actions taken truthful acold successful support of the U.S. robotics ecosystem."

Reposting Carr's X post, Doshi compared the move to the FCC's announcement past December regarding restrictions connected caller foreign-made drones.

"The FCC's drone action was a changeable successful the limb for the home drone industry, and I deliberation this has that aforesaid imaginable successful robotics," Doshi wrote.

Doshi was the lawman elder head for China and Taiwan connected the National Security Council nether erstwhile President Joe Biden.

Peter Harrell, a visiting clever clever astatine Georgetown's Institute of International Economic Law, called the prohibition an "important nationalist information move," adding that precocious robots cod immense amounts of information and are integrated into cardinal industries.

"This should supply a important tailwind to U.S. and allied inverter and robot manufacturers," Harrell wrote connected X. He said the move will protect the US marketplace and create abstraction for its companies to expand.

In an X station connected Tuesday, ambiance investor Ramez Naam described the caller prohibition arsenic a "double-edged sword."

"Short term, the remainder of the world will person entree to amended cheaper hum/quad robots than the US," he wrote. "Longer term, pinch luck, US manufacture will thrive. But China will person advantage of a larger marketplace indefinitely."

He said that humanoid robots are a "terrible shape factor" for warfare and are improbable to impact defense. But the prohibition connected quadrupeds, animal-like robots that locomotion connected 4 legs, could person consequences for defense.

Justin Lopas, the laminitis of location artillery strategy supplier Base Power, gave a motion of support to the ban.

"For those successful the know, this is simply a very large deal," Lopas wrote connected X.

The laminitis worked successful manufacturing and mechanical engineering astatine SpaceX and Anduril earlier launching his institution successful 2023.