We spent over $12,000 replacing our carpets with vinyl-plank flooring. It looks very nice, but I regret it every day.

Sep 04, 2026 11:33 PM - 1 week ago 4

Living room pinch greenish walls, ray grey couches, and vinyl-plank flooring adjacent to French doors

Our vinyl-plank floors look really nice, but they're not cleanable — and installing them turned retired to beryllium much than we bargained for. .Lauren Salles Gumpert

When we bought our home, we thought it needed only cosmetic updates — possibly updated appliances and a caller overgarment of paint.

So, we felt beautiful bully astir tackling our first task arsenic homeowners: replacing the floors successful our main downstairs surviving space.

We consulted specialists astatine a home-improvement chain, sewage measurements and estimates, and chose our luxury vinyl-plank flooring.

Between supplies and labor, we were quoted conscionable nether $6,000 to switch each the flooring connected our first floor, which included our surviving room, kitchen, eating area, overgarment closet, and half bath.

Once demolition began, however, we realized the task would return longer and costs much than we had expected.

Problems started to aboveground erstwhile the contractors began to region our floors

First, subcontractors removed the carpet successful our surviving room and the aged hardwoods successful our kitchen. The carpet pulled up beautiful easily, revealing bedewed subflooring adjacent some sets of French doors that opened to our backyard.

They said we'd request to rent a dehumidifier to region the moisture from these floors earlier the caller ones could beryllium installed.

My hubby rushed retired to find one, which we near connected for a fewer days while we (and our dog) tiptoed astir exposed nails and staples connected our bare plywood subfloor. Thankfully, we didn't person kids astatine the time.

From there, we learned our French doors were leaking severely and needed to beryllium replaced — and truthful did a different conception of damaged subflooring that couldn't beryllium salvaged.

Pressed for time, we hired immoderate bully but inexperienced contractors to make the repairs for astir $4,000. (We paid for this correction a twelvemonth later erstwhile our doors needed to beryllium fixed again.)

After respective weeks of waiting and wearing socks astir the location to debar splinters, we were capable to resume our project.

Not very agelong after, 1 of the subcontractors cracked the drywall successful our room while utilizing a crowbar to loosen the planks, which had been nailed to our baseboards.

We felt arsenic if we couldn't drawback a break.

The floors looked awesome erstwhile they were installed, but the issues kept coming

A composite image of h2o marks and bedewed spots connected subflooring and of a raised outlet sticking retired of hardwood flooring.

We've dealt pinch damaged subflooring and a raised outlet that's go a tripping hazard passim this process.  Lauren Salles Gumpert

This task wasn't done erstwhile our vinyl-plank flooring was put down.

Because the vinyl was thinner and little than our aged floors, our toilet and drop-through outlet nary longer sat flush pinch the ground.

We had to salary a plumber to instal a caller flange — a important portion that fits complete the drainage pipe, prevents leaks, and anchors the toilet to the floor. For a while, we lived pinch an elevated outlet successful the mediate of the floor, which created a tripping hazard for our kids.

Also, the vinyl flooring keeps our downstairs overmuch cooler than our carpeted upstairs, wherever our bedrooms are.

This is mostly good successful the summer, but it contributes to a large somesthesia discrepancy successful the winter. I person to support our house's thermostat group connected the little broadside truthful the power doesn't overwhelm america upstairs, but this intends our downstairs gets really cold.

After each of this, we've been hesitant to do much home-improvement projects

Home DEpot bucket down toilet connected apical of vinyl flooring

As soon arsenic we solved 1 problem, it felt for illustration we'd encountered another.  Lauren Salles Gumpert

This "cosmetic" update, which has now costs america good complete $12,000, has frightened america distant from wanting to prosecute different location renovations, specified arsenic updating our bathrooms aliases landscaping our yard.

In fact, I now don't judge astir home-renovation projects are worthy the hassle unless they're functionally necessary. They're seldom arsenic easy arsenic promised, and there's ever a anticipation you'll uncover costly issues aliases origin much problems successful the process.

A batch of the time, I wish we'd near our floors alone. And if I'm honest, my young kids would've preferred the soft carpet to the harder vinyl floors, which I now screen pinch rugs, anyway.

This communicative was primitively published connected October 7, 2024, and astir precocious updated connected September 4, 2026.

Read next

Lauren is simply a freelance writer, Speech-Language Therapist, and aspiring author. She lives successful Virginia Beach pinch her hubby and 3 young kids. You tin link pinch her via Substack (https://livelearnlauren.substack.com/) to publication much of her writing.

More