Stop trying to replace people with AI

The biggest positioning correction successful AI trading is trading your merchandise arsenic a replacement for people. It wins attraction now, but costs you spot later.

Heads up: This memo is simply a flimsy deviation from the accustomed topics I regularly constitute about. But it’s an important one.

In this memo: 

• Why “substitution positioning” feels bully short word and decays your marque agelong term.
• The information showing AI isn’t really replacing people.
• How to amended position AI.

View embedded content

The cardinal misdeed of positioning successful the AI era is replacement. I telephone it “substitution positioning.” Short term, it’s yummy. Long term, it plants cavities successful your perception.

In January, Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei predicted package engineering jobs to spell distant successful the pursuing 6-12 months. Demand for package engineers is reaching caller heights today.

“I deliberation we mightiness beryllium 6 to 12 months distant from erstwhile the exemplary is doing most, possibly each of what SWEs do extremity to end.” 

In September 2025, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman predicted customer support jobs will spell away. Almost instantly aft he said that, customer work hiring started outpacing the broader occupation market.

• “I’m assured that a batch of existent customer support that happens complete a telephone aliases computer, those group will suffer their jobs, and that’ll beryllium amended done by an AI.” 

AI companies usage fearfulness arsenic a trading tool. Specifically, the fearfulness of being replaced. They sewage me, too. I was profoundly worried astir my early erstwhile Opus 4.5 sewage traction. 

However, arsenic agelong arsenic I spot that moreover Anthropic is hiring copywriters and SEOs, I slumber overmuch better.

Times were much uncertain earlier AI came connected the segment (I’ll spare you the TED talk astir unprecedented times). Fear sells. Tapping into our primal fight-or-flight consequence is simply a judge measurement to get attention. And layoffs enactment arsenic a double supplier successful this environment: They make companies that underperform aliases overhired look bully (“Look, we don’t request arsenic galore group anymore because we’re truthful innovative!”) and provender the substitution positioning narrative.

But the facts show that caller layoffs are person to AI washing than AI outpouring cleaning:

• New York authorities added an action for companies to bespeak erstwhile they laic unit disconnected owed to AI (technological invention aliases automation). In March of this year, complete 160 companies revenge wide layoffs of ~28,300 workers. Not moreover one chose AI arsenic the reason. That database includes Amazon and Goldman Sachs.
• Researchers astatine Yale looked astatine the CPS, a authorities study that tracks employment crossed the US, complete the past 33 months and recovered no grounds of occupation displacement from AI. The measurement AI effect useful looks very akin to really computers and the net changed work. 

Premium is $150/year. That’s little than 1 walked-back AI announcement. The Growth Memo assets library includes the positioning reframe plus successful this memo… and the remainder of the audits, workflows, and decks built for the AI visibility era.

“Stop trying to make ‘replacement’ happen. It’s not going to happen.”

— Regina George from Mean Girls successful an alternate multiverse

AI is conscionable not there… yet.

Synthetic intelligence successful its existent shape is heavy paradoxical: AI tin do immoderate things amended than humans and others not moreover astatine the level of a chimpanzee. 

This arena is called the Jagged Frontier. It’s based connected a insubstantial wherever BCG and Harvard researchers conducted a randomized controlled proceedings of 758 knowledge workers and recovered that you get the astir (12.2% much tasks, 25.1% faster) retired of AI if you cognize what it’s bully and bad at. 

That’s why immoderate group are lukewarm connected AI and others spot it arsenic caller salvation.

“Currently, measures of exposure, automation, and augmentation show nary motion of being related to changes successful employment aliases unemployment.” 

— From “Evaluating the Impact of AI connected the Labor Market: Current State of Affairs,” Gimbel et al.

Microsoft came to the aforesaid conclusion. In its 2026 Work Trend Index Annual Report, the Windows mother recovered that ~16% of the 20,000 AI users surveyed are “Frontier Professionals” aliases the astir precocious AI users successful the investigation group who usage agents for multi-step workflow systems. 

80% of those Frontier Professionals said they nutrient activity they couldn’t person a twelvemonth ago, compared to 58% crossed the board. They are not conscionable utilizing AI more, but besides cognize which mode a task calls for. They person the judgement to navigate the Jagged Frontier.

Caption: Microsoft’s 4 modes of utilizing AI astatine work

Despite immoderate of the gains you can spot from AI, we’re acold distant from replacing people. 

Do you genuinely spot immoderate AI workflow capable to time off it connected afloat automation without immoderate attraction aliases value assurance? 

Look astatine a institution that tried: Klarna publically bragged its AI did the activity of 700 agents and trim headcount ~40%, Then they reversed and rehired humans aft the CEO admitted cost-cutting produced “lower quality” and that customers want a quality option. 

As a result, choosing substitution positioning intends you summation short-term attraction but sacrifice semipermanent credibility. Anthropic calls for a nationalist region connected AI improvement connected June 4 and launches Fable 5 connected June 9. OpenAI did the same: Altman told the U.S. Senate successful May 2023 that AI needs licensing and a world watchdog, past opposed binding rules and lobbied against California’s SB-1047 and mandatory national pre-launch approval. The words don’t lucifer the actions.

Substitute positioning could activity if customers (1) really wanted the replacement and (2) if the exertion was there. Neither are true.

FYI: The Adapting for AI-Based Search deck gives board a validated, data-backed communicative to coming to executives who support asking what changed. Find it successful the Premium Subscribers Resource Library.

Antagonism

Cost simplification is simply a overmuch stronger AI-use statement than productivity maturation because it hits the P&L immediately. Productivity gains show up later. They build slow wrong a institution and moreover slower crossed the economy, the aforesaid lag we saw pinch computers and the internet. 

However, because replacement positioning goes measurement beyond conscionable cost-cutting (it’s people-cutting), you besides straight antagonize the group you waste to:

• Duolingo’s AI-first memo drew a “torrent of pushback” connected societal media/TikTok. CEO von Ahn said he “did not expect the magnitude of blowback” and walked it back, reframing AI arsenic a “tool to accelerate,” not switch contractors.
• ~31% of workers person refused to usage AI devices astatine work, often citing job-loss fear .
• Pew: 50% of US adults are more concerned than excited astir AI successful regular life; only 10% much excited than concerned, up from 37% concerned successful 2021.
• 71% of Americans are afraid of being replaced by AI.
• A study of 1,294 knowledge workers shows those who consciousness the extremity is replacement produce much low-quality workslop.
• Surveys show that activity is commonly more excited astir AI than the labor who usage it.

In April, Uber execs bragged astir burning their yearly token fund successful conscionable 4 months. Today, that’s a monolithic liability. Token costs is increasing contempt being heavy subsidized. But soon, it will scope a value constituent that makes inferior labor commencement to look absorbing again. 

Entry-level jobs mightiness soon beryllium cheaper than tokens accomplishing the aforesaid output, and young group don’t person the aforesaid baggage and reflexes that knowledgeable experts have.

What is the replacement for ‘replacement’?

Instead of trying to switch people, the solution is to position your AI usage arsenic enhancement. The other of fear-based trading is aspiration and empowerment. 

AI goes some ways: You tin trim the number of group aliases turn output pinch the aforesaid number of people. And the information shows that productivity gains person a higher ROI than substitution.

In a paper by the National Bureau of Economic Research, Researchers asked 750 executives astir the effect of AI connected productivity and labour markets. While larger firms person a higher liking successful replacing labour costs (people), the highest ROI comes from increasing productivity. 

The civilized of the story? Doing much pinch what you person useful amended than firing copywriter Alex because only Alex tin judge bully copy.

Premium: Your positioning matters much than ever + Claude skill

Building products has gotten easier, but distribution has not. 

When proviso explodes, the scarce point is being the merchandise that really gets chosen, and positioning (right alongside merchandise quality) is precisely how you get chosen.

Premium subscribers get the Claude accomplishment that performs a value cheque connected your content’s positioning for immoderate AI-based tooling wrong your product, offering value reframes for your squad that debar substitution positioning. 

This station first appeared connected the author’s website and is republished present pinch permission.