Red Sox Get A Run When Blue Jays Fail To Record A 4th Out

Aug 12, 2026 07:39 AM - 3 hours ago 2
Cover Of The Official Baseball Rules Book

You astir apt won't find Rule 5.09(c) successful this shot rulebook, but it is successful the existent one. (Photo by Transcendental Graphics/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Last night’s crippled betwixt the Boston Red Sox and the Toronto Blue Jays was delayed for 15 minutes while everyone connected the section checked successful pinch MLB honchos successful New York for an mentation of a norm that it seems that nary 1 astatine Rogers Centre – umpires included – seemed to know*.


*That is not wholly accurate, arsenic Blue Jays pitcher Max Scherzer claimed to not only cognize the norm (“Absolutely; I person seen this before,” he told Blue Jays sideline newsman Hazel May), but that the umpires handled it improperly arsenic they waived Toronto disconnected the section astatine the incorrect time.


Here is simply a little summary of what transpired. See if you tin travel along: It’s the apical of the seventh inning and the Red Sox way 2-0. Second baseman Anthony Seigler singled to lead disconnected the inning, and Connor Wong followed pinch a azygous of his own. Shortstop Nick Sogard past deed a liner to first, which was nabbed by Vladimir Guerrero Jr., who threw to 2nd for an out. This is the first hinge point.

Double Play Or Force Out

If Guerrero caught the shot connected the fly, his propulsion to 2nd would person doubled disconnected Seigler, and location would person been 2 outs and a runner connected first. But since he trapped the ball, the propulsion to 2nd was a unit retired of Wong, pinch Seigler moving to 3rd connected the play. Thus, location was conscionable 1 retired pinch runners connected the corners. The scoreboard usability was apparently confused arsenic well, arsenic they put “2” successful the “outs” column.

Go the 0:17 mark:

Ceddanne Rafaela batted adjacent and deed a soft alert shot to center. With 1 out, it would person been a sacrifice fly. But astir everyone connected the section acted arsenic if location were 2 outs: Center fielder Brett Bateman lazily tossed the autumn toward the infield; Seigler jogged down the 3rd guidelines statement to home; and Wong loafed towards 2nd base.

The Blue Jays yet figured it out, and threw to first to double disconnected Wong, which was the tail extremity of the double play and the extremity of the inning. The Jays past walked disconnected the field, emotion beautiful bully astir maintaining their 2-0 lead. Except…

Seigler – unwittingly, it seems – crossed location sheet earlier Toronto recorded the 3rd retired astatine first guidelines (when Wong near without tagging up). Had the Blue Jays remained connected the field, they could person appealed the play astatine 3rd (because Seigler besides near without tagging up) by tossing the shot to Charles McAdoo, who would person stepped connected 3rd base, fundamentally tripling-off Seigler for the 4th (!) retired of the inning, and denying Boston their lone run.

However, since the squad near the section (which, arsenic stated above, Scherzer claims was encouraged by the umpires, but replay reviews shows was not the case), they mislaid the correct to entreaty the play, and frankincense the tally was allowed to score. What took 15 agelong minutes to fig retired was an mentation of Rule 5.09(c), which reads:

“Any entreaty nether this norm must beryllium made earlier the adjacent pitch, aliases immoderate play aliases attempted play. If the usurpation occurs during a play which ends a half-inning, the entreaty must beryllium made earlier the protect squad leaves the section . . . Appeal plays whitethorn require an umpire to admit an evident ‘fourth out.’”

According to MLB.com, the past clip this happened was April 12, 2009, successful a crippled betwixt the Dodgers and the Diamondbacks. And who was sitting successful the dugout intensely watching that time astatine Chase Field? None different than then-Arizona pitcher Max Scherzer.

More