Alpha School, the network of AI-driven personal schools charging parents up to $75,000 a year, has won backers from Silicon Valley to the Trump administration. Its own data display most of its students aren’t reaching the model’s chief promise.
Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as accelerated in the two math and reading, according to inner data first reported by The New York Times. The findings district as Alpha pushes into community schools, anywhere districts are adopting its application in hopes of fitting additional learning into small time.
What Alpha promises parents
Alpha has no traditional teachers. It employs what it calls “guides,” whose job, according to the company’s promotion materials, is to “make all pupil awareness appreciated and motivated.” Guides don’t scheme lessons or class homework, Fortune reported in September.
The center of the throw is that students volition “learn twice as much as their peers in two hours of academics a day” using TimeBack, an app Alpha markets as an AI tutor. Cofounder MacKenzie Price says the app personalizes and accelerates learning for all student, freeing the remainder of the academy day for workshops on skills specified as community speaking and association building.
The network has grown fast. A spokesman told Fortune in September that Alpha had additional than 1,200 students. The Times put the fig at concerning 1,500 throughout approximately 50 campuses, in row alongside the expansion plans Alpha announced in August.
That throw has drawn AI optimists. “I certainly think using AI fine is a accomplishment in the future, if not the skill, so it’s benevolent of a disservice not to have that in school,” Sarah Cone, a project capitalist whose 8-year-old female attends Alpha’s New York campus, told Fortune in September.
In September 2025, U.S. Education Secretary Linda McMahon toured Alpha’s Austin campus and called its example “the most breathtaking item I’ve seen in learning in a lengthy time.” LinkedIn cofounder Reid Hoffman and hedge prosperity director Bill Ackman have the two publically backed Price and Alpha on X. Even the X document of Elizabeth Holmes, the Theranos originator serving additional than 11 years in jail for fraud, praised Price.
Where students are falling short
Math is the bigger gap. About fractional of K-8 students at Alpha’s personal campuses missed the goal of learning math twice as fast, and approximately one in five missed their study targets, according to the Times‘ assessment of the network’s data.
Students who started rearward fared worse. About a fifth of Alpha’s personal academy students scored at or below the 50th percentile nationally in math final fall, and lone 37% of that collection met the network’s 2x growth goal by winter, the Times found.
The two-hour premise is additionally in question. Guides and parents told Wired that students worked delayed into the night to encounter the school’s goals. One genitor of a 13-year-old study at an 11th-grade flat stated reaching those goals came alongside “stress and anxiety.”
Former workforce told 404 Media that Alpha’s AI generated faulty instruction plans, which inner documents stated sometimes did “more damage than good,” and that the business scraped another online courses without permission.
Alpha’s example is reaching community schools
More than 2,600 community academy students in Texas and South Carolina now use Alpha’s platform, according to business documents reviewed by the Times. That is a tougher test: community schools can’t eliminate struggling students, the Times noted, and they deficiency the award incentives Alpha uses at its personal campuses.
The Houston Independent School District, the largest in Texas, is piloting the application at two schools. Superintendent Mike Miles told the Times that students spent additional period on Alpha’s apps than planned, cutting into another activities. He motionless wants AI in the district’s toolkit, calling it an crucial tool for students to be “successful in a distinct earth and workplace.”
Research points to a learning penalty
Alpha’s enlargement comes as schools grapple alongside falling math and study scores and expanding evidence that how students use AI matters as much as whether they use it.
A study of 26,811 secondary students in chief China established that homework scores rosy 18% following students adopted generative AI tools, during closed-book exam scores cut 20%. The OECD’s latest PISA results established that regular AI users scored lesser in discipline than nonusers, during moderate users performed concerning the same.
Professors have told Fortune that students who lean on AI summaries battle alongside sustained reading. “Today, if you allocate that amount of reading, they frequently don’t cognize what to do,” Timothy O’Malley, a theology prof at the University of Notre Dame, told Fortune‘s Preston Fore in June.
“It’s not equal an inability to critically think,” Jessica Hooten Wilson, a prof of awesome books and human sciences at Pepperdine University, told Fortune. “It’s an inability to peruse sentences.”