It is a sign of the times that Amazon gets to call this fair use

Aug 21, 2026 07:34 AM - 3 weeks ago 6

This 404 report justly been getting sizeable coverage.

Amazon is buying monolithic quantities of books, scanning them for AI training data, and destroying them successful the process. 

A 404 Media investigation was capable to uncover Amazon’s book buying operation, which hasn’t been antecedently reported, by placing a search device successful a uncommon book we suspected would beryllium acquired by an AI institution for training data, and pursuing it astir the state to its last destination. 

That last destination was an Amazon storage successful Las Vegas, Nevada. Amazon employees who activity astatine this location opportunity each they do is person monolithic shipments of printed books which they past trim the bindings disconnected successful order to scan the books much quickly. The printed book is destroyed successful the process. The logo of the Amazon squad that useful astatine this warehouse, called VGT3, is simply a dinosaur, brandishing its teeth and pinch a book successful its hands.

...

We’re not revealing the titles of the books included successful the shipment we tracked, but they are rare, meaning location are not galore copies of them successful circulation. Sometimes that’s because not galore copies of them were ever printed, and sometimes because they are successful a overseas connection not galore people speak. As the bookseller who sold them told me, location are not many group successful the world who would attraction astir them successful the aforesaid measurement people mightiness attraction astir the first version of Oliver Twist, but that doesn’t mean they’re not valuable. 

“There are different types of value,” the bookseller said. “There's monetary value, obviously, but location are a batch of different types of value. There's historical value, intelligence value, sentimental value. All sorts of things, and each of those the AI companies don't attraction about. They conscionable want the contented arsenic a bunch of words strung together.”

As mentioned elsewhere, this is besides IP theft connected a monolithic scale. 

There is, however, 1 facet which hasn't gotten to play it deserves, namely really a genuinely ethical and nationalist spirited institution handles the aforesaid problem.

Scanning each the Books: The Work of Scribes for the Internet Archive
Anne-Laure Freant

In 1996, machine technologist Brewster Kahle founded the Internet Archive pinch the ngo to supply "universal entree to each knowledge." Today, that imagination drives the methodical activity happening successful scanning centers wherever operators cautiously digitize books 1 page astatine a time, preserving some the contented and the beingness integrity of centuries-old volumes.

The Internet Archive's attack stems from a basal disagreement pinch the digitization methods that emerged successful the early 2000s. When Google launched its Books task successful 2004, it revolutionized the standard of integer libraries but introduced a troubling trade-off: speed versus preservation. Google's business attack often progressive destructive scanning—cutting book spines and dismantling bindings to facilitate rapid automated processing.

The Internet Archive chose a different path. "At the Internet Archive, we ne'er destruct a book by cutting disconnected its binding. Instead, we digitize it the difficult way, 1 page astatine a time". That led to the adjustment of machines and package to fresh the very specific intent of the Internet Archive, and to a job: book scanner, or scribe operator.

Just to beryllium clear, the destructive method is faster and cheaper but fixed the tremendous resources of Amazon and the spectacular magnitude of money that has been spent and successful galore cases demonstrably wasted pumping up the AI bubble, that's not overmuch of an excuse. Arguably moreover worse erstwhile you retrieve this is each going to train the latest of Amazon's crappy Nova series. 

This was a prime they made, conscionable for illustration mounting up monolithic fossil substance powerfulness plants now alternatively than taking the clip to summation atomic and renewable capacity was a choice, conscionable for illustration stealing the intelligence spot of countless writers and artists was a choice, conscionable for illustration rolling retired products that weren't fresh for premier clip was a choice, conscionable for illustration setting up ridiculously astatine analyzable and deceptive financing schemes rather than increasing the manufacture successful a sustainable measurement was a choice.

More