I made a sandwich in my air fryer every day for a week. Here are the 6 easy recipes I'd happily make again.

If you emotion toasty sandwiches but want to debar utilizing a grill, oven, aliases stovetop, the aerial fryer is astir to beryllium your champion friend.

For one, I've made countless things successful my aerial fryer, from corn "ribs" to chocolate-chip cookies, and person seldom been fto down. I tin besides corroborate that utilizing an aerial fryer to make sandwiches results successful crunchy, delicious magic — but immoderate recipes are much worthy the effort than others. 

So, I made 7 sandwiches successful my aerial fryer to spot which would gain a spot successful my regular repast rotation. Here's really it went.

I started disconnected by making a meatball sub

I started my week pinch a meatball-sub look from the nutrient blog Project Meal Plan.

First, to make the meatballs, I utilized my hands to harvester ingredients specified arsenic crushed pork, ground beef, pesto, breadcrumbs, eggs, and seasonings.

I rolled the nutrient substance into balls and placed them connected a cooky expanse lined pinch a portion of foil coated pinch cooking spray. I placed these successful the oven astatine 375 degrees Fahrenheit for 25 minutes.

By the clip they came retired of the oven, they looked beautiful tasty. To beryllium clear, if I wanted to skip this step, the look says frozen meatballs would beryllium good arsenic well.

A toasted bun is simply a necessity pinch a sub

I utilized a brioche hot-dog bun arsenic a substitute for a hoagie roll.

I placed a buttered bun successful the preheated aerial fryer astatine 400 degrees Fahrenheit for 2 minutes, past topped it pinch caller mozzarella and cooked it until the food was toasty.

As this toasted, I warmed up a spot of herb condiment for later. Once my cheesy bun was ready, I topped it pinch meatballs and sauce.

This was a satisfying sandwich

This sub was delicious, filling, and worthy the effort. 

The bun was toasty and aureate brown, the food was nicely melted, and the meatballs were other tasty acknowledgment to the pesto and seasonings successful the mixture.

I would perfectly make this again.

At first, the mac-and-cheese toastie didn't make overmuch consciousness to me 

Next, I decided to measurement retired of my comfortableness area pinch a sandwich I'd ne'er had before. I followed nutrient blogger Oh My Veggies' look for a grilled food that includes a information of cooked mac and cheese.

To start, I buttered 2 slices of breadstuff and topped 1 pinch a portion of cheddar. I besides piled immoderate pre-cooked mac and food successful the middle.

I stuck my sandwich successful a preheated aerial fryer astatine 360 degrees Fahrenheit for astir 3 aliases 4 minutes connected each side. 

This unsocial sandwich came retired tasty and cheesy

This tasted delicious and, for those who emotion cheese, it's decidedly a winner. If you scheme to make this, I propose utilizing thicker breadstuff to clasp the mac and food better. 

I still for illustration my mac and cheese and grilled food separate, but this look tin besides beryllium utilized to make a basal sandwich. 

When I followed this look without macaroni, it came retired cheesy, crunchy, and buttery. This was an easy way to make grilled cheese without having to get a cookware retired and hold to fry some sides.

The chickenhearted Caprese panini turned retired to beryllium 1 of my favorites

For this sandwich, I followed a look from the nutrient blog Cook the Story. 

To start, I butterflied a chickenhearted breast, put brackish and capsicum connected some sides, and air-fried it for 13 minutes full astatine 375 degrees Fahrenheit, flipping halfway through.

Next, I mixed adjacent parts mayonnaise and pesto to create my condiment and extremity my sandwich from being excessively dry.

To decorativeness prepping my ingredients, I thinly sliced my tomatoes and mozzarella.

I quickly assembled this sandwich and popped it successful the aerial fryer

I slathered my pesto-mayo substance connected some sides of the roll, placed the chickenhearted connected 1 side, and topped it pinch sliced tomatoes and mozzarella.

I placed it successful the aerial fryer, sprayed the breadstuff pinch oil, and cooked it for 5 minutes astatine 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Midway done air-frying, I mildly pressed the sandwich down to create a panini effect.

This was the cleanable operation of crunchiness, cheesiness, and juiciness 

This was truthful juicy acknowledgment to the well-cooked chicken. The melty mozzarella added the cleanable cheesy touch, and the pesto-mayo substance added truthful overmuch herby flavor.

Overall, the sandwich was filling and delicious. Although it was big, it stayed together perfectly successful the aerial fryer and didn't autumn isolated arsenic I ate it.

To move things up, I tried making a classical sausage, egg, and cheese

For my adjacent sandwich, I group my sights connected breakfast. I followed a since-deleted look from a random nutrient blog I'd recovered online to make this, but it's truthful elemental that I'm not judge I needed 1 astatine all.

First, I collapsed isolated an English muffin, buttered some sides, and topped 1 pinch a portion of cheddar cheese. Both halves went into my air-fryer handbasket on pinch a pre-cooked sausage patty.

I air-fried my sandwich ingredients astatine 390 degrees Fahrenheit for 3 minutes — until the muffin sewage toasty, the sausage warmed, and the food melted.

Then, I microwaved an egg successful a mug for astir 90 seconds, checking connected it each 30 seconds, until it was coagulated and cooked. This would spell betwixt my English-muffin slices to complete the sandwich.

This meal sandwich was delicious and turned retired perfectly

Taste-wise, this was a hit. I could spot myself getting a breakfast sandwich for illustration this from a edifice aliases deli. The flavors were balanced, and the cheese, butter, and somewhat jammy ovum stopped it from being excessively dry.

Making this pinch an aerial fryer (and microwave) felt overmuch simpler than toasting the bread, cooking the patty, and frying an ovum separately.

This is besides really easy to dress up pinch basking condiment aliases different cheeses and meats. I deliberation bacon could activity really good alternatively of sausage.

All successful all, it's a tasty and easy meal sandwich that tin decidedly beryllium thrown together connected engaged mornings.

This was my first clip making a Monte Cristo sandwich

I loosely followed an air-fryer Monte Cristo look from nutrient blogger The Typical Mom. I opted to usage Gouda cheese, which I deliberation is tastier than cheddar aliases Swiss, and not see turkey slices.

First, I assembled a elemental sandwich pinch my breadstuff of choice, sliced ham, and aged Gouda.

Once my sandwich was assembled, I pressed it down pinch my manus and secured it pinch 4 toothpicks, per the recipe's instructions.

I besides had to make pancake batter for this recipe

A Monte Cristo is simply a sweet-and-savory sandwich that's usually dipped successful ovum and cooked benignant of for illustration a French toast. For this air-fryer recipe, that saccharine crispiness would travel from a furniture of pancake batter.

I followed the directions connected my buttermilk pancake mix, but utilized a small little liquid to support my batter connected the thicker side. This way, the sandwich would beryllium easier to evenly coat.

I dipped the sandwich successful the batter and made judge to fto the excess drip off. Then, I placed the dipped sandwich onto a parchment-paper liner I had punctured respective times to guarantee airflow. Into my aerial fryer it went.

I air-fried the sandwich for 7 minutes connected 1 side, past flipped and cooked for a infinitesimal much astatine 380 degrees Fahrenheit.

I wish I'd utilized cooking spray earlier putting the sandwich successful the fryer, since it stuck a spot erstwhile I flipped it. Still, it stayed mostly intact.

Once it was aureate brownish and ready, I opted not to particulate my sandwich pinch powdered sweetener arsenic the look suggests — but I'm judge that would person been delicious.

This was ace tasty and worthy the effort

My sandwich was indulgent, filling, and other tasty acknowledgment to the coating of pancake batter that created a crunchy, buttery exterior.

Each wound was a cheesy and satisfying experience. In general, immoderate Monte Cristo variety feels for illustration a awesome sandwich to make successful an aerial fryer.

Lastly, I made a basal sandwich using leftover nutrient

For this produce-packed sandwich, I improvised aft reference a fewer different recipes online.

I started by air-frying sliced mushrooms for 5 minutes astatine 390 degrees Fahrenheit, past mounting them aside. You tin besides adhd different produce, for illustration doorbell peppers, during this measurement — thing you want to navigator a small longer.

I assembled the sandwich by spreading pesto connected some pieces of bread, past layering cheddar cheese, cooked mushrooms, and sliced cherry tomatoes.

I sprayed the breadstuff pinch cooking spray truthful it'd get crispy and aureate brown, past popped it successful the aerial fryer.

I air-fried the sandwich astatine 350 degrees Fahrenheit for conscionable a fewer minutes, until the breadstuff was golden-brown, the tomatoes had blistered, and the food was melted.

This look is simply a awesome measurement to usage up leftovers

This customizable veggie sandwich of sorts was tasty and simple. It could easy beryllium made pinch a assortment of cheeses, spreads, aliases leftover produce.

Next time, I'd usage a heariter sourdough breadstuff to amended guidelines up to the contents of my sandwich. It started to autumn isolated a small spot arsenic I ate.

The apical of my sandwich blew disconnected successful the aerial fryer earlier it was done, truthful I'd besides put food connected some slices of breadstuff successful the future. Melty food is genuinely what binds a sandwich together.

Overall, I'd make 6 of these sandwiches again

Each air-fryer sandwich was easy to make and yielded a melty, toasty consequence that mightiness different require a panini shaper to make.

My favorites were the meatball sub and chickenhearted Caprese, some of which could easy beryllium the prima components of a afloat meal.

I wouldn't make the mac-and-cheese grilled food again, but I tin spot a batch of others enjoying it. Fortunately, the tasty recipe is easy to adapt, and I deliberation it's awesome without the pasta.

All successful all, aft a week of making these, I'm assured you tin beautiful overmuch air-fry immoderate sandwich to make it other hot, crispy, and delicious.

This communicative was primitively published connected January 25, 2022, and astir precocious updated connected July 26, 2026.