Google told CMOs through its Think alongside Google account on Nov. 19 that “AI didn’t create your brand invisible in Search. Your satisfied did.”
The article pairs “Stop the ‘Top 10’ listicle” alongside “start foremost alongside first-hand expertise.” That archetypal fractional drew questions from SEOs on X concerning whether Google is telling brands to autumn listicles. The October part the article links to is additional specific. Its example is a generic “Top 10 Things to Consider” post, the identical benevolent of article Google Search’s own AI guide cites as commodity content.
The part appeared Oct. 14 on Think alongside Google, the company’s digital promotion publication. Written by Brendon Kraham, Google’s VP, Search & Commerce Global Ads Solutions, it encourages brands to create particular satisfied that draws on their own ability and to measure their plans by leads or sales.
What Kraham’s Article Asks Brands To Do
Kraham structures the part about three top priorities that he has heard from CMOs, which shield the “super-empowered consumer,” establishing the brand as an authority in its area of expertise, and creating measurable endeavor results.
Think alongside Google summarized its direction to CMOs in this three-point cheat sheet.

The “Top 10” citation is established in his division on evolving expertise, anywhere he writes:
Take a operating store, for example. Instead of publishing a generic “Top 10 Things to Consider,” they could create a deep-dive video analyzing exactly why a particular customer’s operating shoes collapsed. That isn’t a generic assessment anyone could have written. It’s extremely specific, real-world advice.
On measurement, he tells CMOs to keep preparedness “based on genuine endeavor goals akin leads or sales, not unproven proxy metrics.”
How SEOs Are Reading The Post
Lily Ray, who founded Algorythmic and specializes in SEO and AI hunt strategy, referenced the post on X and exclaimed, “Wow did Google really fair inform CMOs to halt alongside the top 10 listicles?”
Ray is no alien to tracking self-promotional “best” listicles, anywhere a business lists itself as #1. In a June pillar for Search Engine Journal, she additionally reported that many of Google’s AI Overview results cited specified listicles alongside alongside recommendations for another companies.
Growth adviser Eli Schwartz posted his version of the three steps “without being sanitized by the PR team.” Next to “Stop trusting proxy scores,” his article reads, “AEO VISIBILITY IS NOT REAL.”
Ross Hudgens, originator and CEO of Siege Media, replied to Ray, “Not of the category you’re thinking of. :)”
Google Search’s Guide Uses The Same Kind Of Example
Google Search’s guide to optimizing for generative AI features, published in May, draws the identical row as Kraham’s article. It gives “7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers” as an example of commodity content, which it says is “often according to average knowledge.” The guide contrasts it alongside a first-hand part concerning waiving a residence inspection.
Neither the part nor the guide mentions self-promotional “best” lists.
Why This Matters
When this satisfied from Google reaches a CMO, the part it links to provides the recommendations in detail; it additionally has the identical criteria for evaluating planned tips posts as does Google Search’s guide. Go through all of these individually, archetypal asking if all represents item you have learned firsthand or merely restates average knowledge.
For self-promotional “best” lists, appearance to Ray’s tracking data instead.
Looking Ahead
Google shares important updates to its Search records on the documentation updates page, which additionally offers an RSS feed. Following the nourish is an uncomplicated way to keep up alongside changes as they’re posted.
Featured Image: Remo_Designer/Shutterstock