From A-Z, Mamdani’s Amazon Fight Could Reshape Last-Mile Delivery

NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who has backed the Delivery Protection Act, speaks astatine a May Day rally successful New York City. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

Getty Images

New York City has a love-hate narration pinch Amazon and the transportation vehicles that litter the city. The latest section of this romanticist play is picking up heat, arsenic Mayor Zohran Mamdani has officially backed a measure aimed mostly astatine Amazon.

Context matters because this conflict extends beyond Amazon, New York City aliases the analyzable history they share. The Delivery Protection Act asks Amazon and different carriers utilizing Delivery Service Partners (DSPs) to commit. Instead, Amazon is threatening to move out. How this quarrel plays retired could reshape last-mile transportation operations, subcontracted labour models and broader gig-worker policies crossed the country.

What NYC’s Delivery Protection Act Delivers

Int 518-2026, introduced connected February 12, 2026, is the successor to measure Int 1396-2025. The measure was primitively introduced adjacent the extremity of the legislative convention successful September 2025 by City Council Member Tiffany Cabán. Both versions of the measure are referred to publically arsenic the Delivery Protection Act.

The instauration of the measure is simply a licensing request for last-mile facilities. Licenses would beryllium handled by the metropolis and found cosmopolitan standards specified arsenic training requirements, liability sum and information and retention policies. The licence itself is nominal astatine an yearly interest of $500 for each location and would stay valid for a two-year period. The astir economically important facet of the bill, however, comes from its conditions connected employment.

Currently, Amazon utilizes a web of complete 40 independent Delivery Service Partners (DSPs) which employment much than 5,000 workers. Amazon substantially controls these workers’ hours, hiring practices, routes, uniforms, vehicles and quotas for these workers, yet they are not Amazon employees. They are moreover required to deterioration Amazon uniforms and run Amazon-branded vehicles. Although Amazon will salary for definite tickets the vehicles incur, immoderate incidents involving the workers are the work of the subcontractor. This measure fundamentally asserts that if it looks for illustration a duck, and useful for illustration a duck, it’s a duck.

If enacted, the measure would require installation operators, specified arsenic Amazon, to straight employment immoderate workers who execute halfway services for them. Core services see some halfway transportation services and halfway storage services. With constricted exceptions, third-party contracts would beryllium expressly prohibited. The measure includes astir a one-year grace play pinch immoderate exceptions, on pinch a conception connected worker retention. Facility operators must connection to rehire immoderate terminated third-party workers earlier offering to prosecute immoderate different workers arsenic employees. It besides stipulates their rights, privileges, and benefits shouldn’t beryllium little than their existing contracts.

The measure presently sits pinch the Committee connected Consumer and Worker Protection (CCWP). Although the measure has capable assembly members backing it to represent a supermajority which protects it from consequence of a veto, it has not been scheduled for a committee vote. In April, the measure was laid complete by the committee, efficaciously pausing it. So why each the attraction connected the measure if it’s paused?

The measure has gained much attraction pursuing Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s nationalist backing of the measure successful August 2026. The backing was paired pinch a nationalist relations run successful support of the legislation, heavy calling retired Amazon arsenic a cardinal target of the bill. A campaign, backed mostly by Amazon, has spent complete $5 million connected a run of its ain to reason the legislation, which highlights really earnestly some sides are taking this debate.

When un-paused, the measure would request to person a committee ballot followed by a level vote. Although the committee chair is the first statement of approval, the City Council Speaker controls each legislative agendas. Some advocates of the measure declare it was being efficaciously blocked by the City Council’s Speaker. This position was held formerly by Adrienne Adams who has been replaced by Julie Menin starting successful January. While the measure is connected pause, some sides are mounting their lobbying campaigns which would efficaciously spot unit connected Menin.

Why NYC And Amazon Need To Kiss And Make Up

The stakes are high. This measure has the imaginable to reshape the unit ecosystem surrounding 1 of the astir captious markets for retail. An estimated 2.5 cardinal packages are delivered crossed NYC each day. NYC residents are premier candidates for e-commerce orders fixed the usage of nationalist transportation, debased rates of car ownership and deficiency of proximity to large container retailers. Mayor Mamdani cited the emergence successful e-commerce arsenic 1 logic for the bill. As e-commerce has reshaped retail, the building of the workforce evolved arsenic well.

This conflict besides places workers, mini businesses and consumers successful an different triangle. Supporters of the measure reason that companies controlling last-mile transportation networks should beryllium accountable for the group performing their halfway functions. Dissenters of the measure reason that eliminating subcontracting would alternatively destruct independent businesses that already employment those workers. This makes the statement materially different from past legislation surrounding labour practices for application-based businesses for illustration Uber, Lyft, DoorDash and Instacart.

There could besides beryllium consequences for consumers. An Amazon-supported study estimates the argumentation could costs NYC households an mean of $664 annually. The backing down the estimate is an important context, but truthful is the economical accusation it highlights. Higher labour and operating costs yet person to beryllium absorbed somewhere, whether by Amazon, its suppliers, workers aliases consumers. NYC has faced versions of this tradeoff before.

The metropolis established minimum salary standards for app-based nutrient transportation workers while allowing platforms to support their underlying labour models. This subsequently showed up connected customer receipts astatine immoderate transportation platforms arsenic a regulatory fee statement item. The Delivery Protection Act goes a important measurement further by perchance eliminating the subcontracting narration for halfway last-mile activity altogether.

Other NYC authorities has likewise tested really acold the metropolis should spell successful assigning work to the institution yet benefiting from a service. The 2024 Safe Hotels Act placed ineligible requirements connected hotels and their usage of subcontracted workers. Consumer protection efforts involving click-to-cancel requirements, self-storage companies and forbidden towing person besides demonstrated the city’s willingness to intervene successful relationships it views arsenic imbalanced.

The mobility pinch Amazon is really overmuch involution 1 of the country’s astir important unit markets tin sorb without changing the convenience consumers person travel to expect.

Amazon And NYC Have Relationship Issues

This is hardly Amazon and NYC’s first quarrel.

In 2018, Amazon selected Long Island City for portion of its projected 2nd headquarters, commonly known arsenic HQ2. New York initially courted the institution pinch billions of dollars successful incentives successful speech for the committedness of caller jobs. The narration quickly deed the rocks amid governmental and nationalist guidance complete incentives, labour practices, lodging concerns and Amazon’s increasing power. Amazon canceled the task successful 2019.

The breakup did not support Amazon retired of New York. Its logistics beingness has continued to grow pinch a reported 10 distribution hubs. Amazon trucks, vans, bikes and workers person been a acquainted portion of the city’s streetscape, racking up parking and postulation violations on the way. The Mamdani management has pursued Amazon complete millions of dollars successful conveyance idling fines. They person notably recovered more than $9 million, holding the institution accountable for costs created by its DSP.

Then location was the Met Gala. Amazon laminitis Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez Bezos were awesome financial sponsors and became honorary chairs of the 2026 event. This generated backlash from activists and others captious of Amazon. Protesters utilized the arena to tie attraction to Amazon’s labour practices by projecting video onto Bezos’ Manhattan penthouse flat building.

The narration is complicated. A metropolis that loves its workers besides loves the convenience Amazon provides its residents with, creating a conflict of conscience.

Could Amazon Ghost NYC Or Will They Become A Model Couple?

NYC believes this is successful the champion liking of NYC workers. Amazon argues these accrued costs and transportation clip yet effect consumers, of which location are a batch of them successful NYC. Business owners of the subcontracted transportation services reason they would beryllium put retired of business. There appears to beryllium nary clear victor connected either broadside of the argument.

In a testimony made by Amazon to the NYC Council Committee connected Consumer and Worker Protection, the institution many times mentions the imaginable for relocating operations and transportation accommodation extracurricular of New York City. It appears 3 times successful fact, crossed a four-page document, while highlighting the risks to jobs and mini businesses it imposes.

That does not mean Amazon would extremity trading to New Yorkers. The precedent was already group pinch its HQ2 breakup. Moving last-mile transportation respective miles farther away, however, is simply a possibility. This could lead to accrued proscription costs, extended transportation clip and further vehicles connected the road. NYC tolls unsocial person risen sharply successful caller years owed to congestion pricing. Moving distribution points further to toll-heavy areas specified arsenic New Jersey could further compound costs.

Whether Amazon absorbs those costs aliases passes immoderate information on to the consumers would go a business decision. Long region relationships are ne'er easy, and moving retired whitethorn besides not lick these challenges.

The Teamsters, formally known arsenic the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, are a awesome labour national which represents workers crossed logistics, transportation, warehousing and different industries. They assert that the position of the measure would still use to covered workers operating successful the city, sloppy of wherever Amazon’s accommodation are located. They person besides vowed to usage this authorities arsenic a exemplary crossed the country, making it difficult for Amazon to conscionable locomotion out. Although the bill’s meaning of halfway transportation services supports the Teamsters interpretation, applying the rule to an cognition extracurricular the city’s jurisdiction could invite litigation complete its reach.

The outcome, however, could scope acold beyond NYC. If the metropolis successfully becomes the first to modulate last-mile operations, labour unions are apt to guarantee it isn’t the last. However, if costs emergence and businesses adjacent without measurable betterment successful worker conditions and roadworthy safety, the authorities could alternatively go a informing for different cities considering akin laws.